• Re: Lynn?s six star list in September 2026

    From Titus G@3:633/10 to All on Sat Nov 21 10:30:02 2026
    On 20/11/2026 17:45, Lynn McGuire wrote:
    On 11/19/2026 8:24 PM, Titus G wrote:
    On 20/11/2026 10:44, Lynn McGuire wrote:

    Lynn?s six star list in September 2026:

    Our tastes are quite different.

    Where is your top shelf list?


    Coming shortly to a newsgroup near you.


    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From Titus G@3:633/10 to All on Sat Nov 21 11:29:01 2026
    On 20/11/2026 17:46, Lynn McGuire wrote:
    On 11/19/2026 8:24 PM, Titus G wrote:
    On 20/11/2026 10:44, Lynn McGuire wrote:

    Lynn?s six star list in September 2026:

    Our tastes are quite different. I have snipped books I have not read.

    Robert Heinlein

    His style is now too dated to reread. Everything he has written has been
    rewritten with massive improvement....

    So which books of Heinlein's have been replaced with which books?


    From your own list, Old Man's War updates Starship Troopers according to Scalzi.

    I have forgotten most of Heinlein so have asked a friend.

    McDonald?s Luna trilogy is probably the closest in scope and ambition as
    a ?modern Moon is a Harsh Mistress?; same core setting and
    political/economic DNA, but written with contemporary sensibilities,
    deeper character work across a large cast, and less idealism about pure freedom. Grok.



    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From Scott Dorsey@3:633/10 to All on Fri Nov 20 22:10:47 2026
    In article <11dqhkb$3igr5$2@dont-email.me>, Titus G <noone@nowhere.com> wrote: >On 20/11/2026 17:46, Lynn McGuire wrote:

    So which books of Heinlein's have been replaced with which books?

    From your own list, Old Man's War updates Starship Troopers according to >Scalzi.

    I think also Haldeman has done some very different riffs on that story,
    but to be honest I still think Starship Troopers holds up in spite of it
    being a bit rough around the edges.

    Likewise I think people should read SiaSL even though most of the ideas presented there are no longer particularly radical or even unusual. But please, please don't build your life around it.

    I think that Heinlein's literary style is definitely on the rough and
    pulplike side, but not in an offensive way. It holds up better than
    Asimov's does at times.

    I have forgotten most of Heinlein so have asked a friend.

    McDonald?s Luna trilogy is probably the closest in scope and ambition as
    a ?modern Moon is a Harsh Mistress?; same core setting and
    political/economic DNA, but written with contemporary sensibilities,
    deeper character work across a large cast, and less idealism about pure >freedom. Grok.

    I have not read this! Should I?
    --scott
    --
    "C'est un Nagra. C'est suisse, et tres, tres precis."

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From William Hyde@3:633/10 to All on Sat Nov 21 14:20:59 2026
    Scott Dorsey wrote:
    In article <11dqhkb$3igr5$2@dont-email.me>, Titus G <noone@nowhere.com> wrote:
    On 20/11/2026 17:46, Lynn McGuire wrote:

    So which books of Heinlein's have been replaced with which books?

    From your own list, Old Man's War updates Starship Troopers according to
    Scalzi.

    I think also Haldeman has done some very different riffs on that story,
    but to be honest I still think Starship Troopers holds up in spite of it being a bit rough around the edges.

    I can only read it as a dystopia. But as a dystopia, it works.

    Likewise I think people should read SiaSL even though most of the ideas presented there are no longer particularly radical or even unusual. But please, please don't build your life around it.

    Recalling the book brings faint feelings of nausea. Despite there being
    good things in it.

    If I were to reread a Heinlein novel now it would be one of Double Star,
    Glory Road, or The Moon is a Harsh Mistress.

    Possibly Job, of which I recall virtually nothing. But I think I
    enjoyed it. And maybe I should give Friday another shot.

    I would enjoy reading one of the short story collections.

    I retain very fond memories of most of the juveniles, and prefer to keep
    them that way.


    I think that Heinlein's literary style is definitely on the rough and pulplike side, but not in an offensive way.

    For me RAH is above all a good storyteller. When his obsessions work
    with the story the result is very good indeed, when they interfere with
    the tale, not so much.



    It holds up better than
    Asimov's does at times.

    Years ago I read Second Foundation and followed it up with Foundation's
    edge. While I much prefer the former, It struck me that the prose in
    the latter was superior.


    William Hyde

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5.19
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)