Dear alt.usage.english,
ÿÿÿÿ rec.arts.sf.written,
ÿÿÿÿ alt.books.raymond-feist,
ÿÿÿÿ alt.literature,
I've been listening to /Shadow of a Dark Queen/ by Raymond E. Feist, and
the narrator -- I didn't look up his name -- pronounces /Arutha/ as
Aroota, with a T.
As a teenager in Iceland, I always used to sub-vocalize [1] it as
Arootha with a thorn.ÿ I don't speak IPA so I left the fancy symbolism
out of this Usenet post.
Now the question is, what /traditions/ do English speakers use to guess
such pronunciations?ÿ It's apparently a guess if Anthony is pronounced
with a Thorn [2] or a T, based on a recent discussion in alt.usage.eng-
lish.ÿ So, for fictional names like /Arutha/ -- at least, I don't rem-
ember encountering it in the real world -- what is the hint it should be
a T, and not Thurz?
Best wishes, and happy pronunciation!
[1] Isn't that the term for not vocalizing what we're thinking?
[2] Actually, /Thurz/ if I remember my Elder Futhark correctly, but the
name got changed in Iceland, and forgotten in England.ÿ My guess is
something about religious intolerance against a heathen script, which is
not a valid reason not to use it today; yet the Oxford English Diction-
ary, or its editors, are lazy at picking it up again.
On 11/19/26 19:23, Johann 'Myrkraverk' Oskarsson wrote:
Dear alt.usage.english,
ÿÿÿÿÿ rec.arts.sf.written,
ÿÿÿÿÿ alt.books.raymond-feist,
ÿÿÿÿÿ alt.literature,
I've been listening to /Shadow of a Dark Queen/ by Raymond E. Feist, and
the narrator -- I didn't look up his name -- pronounces /Arutha/ as
Aroota, with a T.
ÿÿÿÿArutha with the th which has replaced the chararter thorn.
ÿÿÿÿI grew up with no knowlege of the thorn character and learned
about it as an adult. And nearly everyone I talk to would use
the same sounding of the name.
As a teenager in Iceland, I always used to sub-vocalize [1] it as
Arootha with a thorn.ÿ I don't speak IPA so I left the fancy symbolism
out of this Usenet post.
Now the question is, what /traditions/ do English speakers use to guess
such pronunciations?ÿ It's apparently a guess if Anthony is pronounced
with a Thorn [2] or a T, based on a recent discussion in alt.usage.eng-
lish.ÿ So, for fictional names like /Arutha/ -- at least, I don't rem-
ember encountering it in the real world -- what is the hint it should be
a T, and not Thurz?
ÿÿÿÿThe type setter lost it for some reason and "th" is
the 2 character replacement.
ÿÿÿÿIn establishments which wish to project a certain
air the Th is replaced with a script Thorn which looks
like, a fancy y and which fools pronounce as a Y. As in
ye olde book store or ye old wine bar or ye old tea shoppe.
But they are pronounced properly as the old tea shop, etc.
ÿÿÿÿPerhaps it was lost because the character was too
hard to carve and was fragile even in lead.
ÿÿÿÿBut it can be represented by small letter ? or
capital letter ? which in fast reading would be confused
with b or p.ÿ I think that th is preferable. 99% of us
modern English speakers would have to look up either
capital or small letter ? and would have no a inkling
of a clue as to what sound it might represent.
ÿÿÿÿAll props to Wikipedia and to kcharselect.
Best wishes, and happy pronunciation!
[1] Isn't that the term for not vocalizing what we're thinking?
[2] Actually, /Thurz/ if I remember my Elder Futhark correctly, but the
name got changed in Iceland, and forgotten in England.ÿ My guess is
something about religious intolerance against a heathen script, which is
not a valid reason not to use it today; yet the Oxford English Diction-
ary, or its editors, are lazy at picking it up again.
ÿÿÿÿAgain the Thorn character is simply obsolescent in standard
English.
ÿÿÿÿI think the th is a very acceptable substitute which most
people will pronounce properly.
ÿÿÿÿWhy the narrator used t I dunno, ask him if you want a
definite answer
ÿÿÿÿbliss
The type setter lost it for some reason and "th" is the 2 character replacement.
On 20/11/26 15:42, bliss wrote:
The type setter lost it for some reason and "th" is the 2 character
replacement.
I believe that Norman scribes introduced th and ch into English,
ignoring the fact that English already had one-letter ways of writing
those sounds. I suspect that this was from sheer laziness. Instead of
working out how English writing worked, they tried to force French
spelling conventions onto English.
The Normans were themselves descendants of Vikings. In what seems like a
very short time, they lost their own language and adopted a dialect of French.
On 11/19/26 21:52, Peter Moylan wrote:
On 20/11/26 15:42, bliss wrote:Probably because it was used by the peasants whom they ordered
The type setter lost it for some reason and "th" is the 2 character
replacement.
I believe that Norman scribes introduced th and ch into English,
ignoring the fact that English already had one-letter ways of writing
those sounds. I suspect that this was from sheer laziness. Instead of
working out how English writing worked, they tried to force French
spelling conventions onto English.
The Normans were themselves descendants of Vikings. In what seems like a
very short time, they lost their own language and adopted a dialect of
French.
around from their fiefs.
But don't blame everything on the Norman Scribes.
look at:<https://www.dictionary.com/articles/letters-alphabet>
On 20/11/26 15:42, bliss wrote:
The type setter lost it for some reason and "th" is the 2 character
replacement.
I believe that Norman scribes introduced th and ch into English,
ignoring the fact that English already had one-letter ways of writing
those sounds. I suspect that this was from sheer laziness. Instead of
working out how English writing worked, they tried to force French
spelling conventions onto English.
The Normans were themselves descendants of Vikings. In what seems like a
very short time, they lost their own language and adopted a dialect of French.
On 11/20/2026 1:52 PM, Peter Moylan wrote:
On 20/11/26 15:42, bliss wrote:
The type setter lost it for some reason and "th" is the 2 character
replacement.
I believe that Norman scribes introduced th and ch into English,
ignoring the fact that English already had one-letter ways of writing
those sounds. I suspect that this was from sheer laziness. Instead of
working out how English writing worked, they tried to force French
spelling conventions onto English.
aThe Normans were themselves descendants of Vikings. In what seems like
very short time, they lost their own language and adopted a dialect of
French.
That's interesting. I had not heard about the Norman scribes doing
this. It kind of supports my theory that it was based on religion, but
also introduces another wrinkle: social superiority. Since the Normen >(grammer?) had taken over England with military force -- I believe it
was 1066 but I'm typing this from memory -- they may simply have dis-
missed any notions coming from the Bri'ish isles about spellings, and >introduced their own out of sheer arrogance.
And yes, that they themselves took up French is well known, and rela-
tively little of their culture remains; I believe boat building is one
of those but now it's considered /thoroughly French/ [1].
Anyway, there are several factors that can explain the language change,
one of which is simply having French women raising their kids. It's my
own observation that when people are talking about language shifts and
such, they rarely want to discuss the cultural shifts and the social re- >ality of the people involved. As if languages just change on their own.
And yes, there are other explanations, but I tend to like this one.
Best wishes, and happy French!--
[1] The hand crafted -- to some degree -- shipping boats, still con-
structed in the Viking fashion, even though the boats look properly
modern.
I've been listening to /Shadow of a Dark Queen/ by Raymond E. Feist, and
the narrator -- I didn't look up his name -- pronounces /Arutha/ as
Aroota, with a T.
Now the question is, what /traditions/ do English speakers use to guess
such pronunciations?
As a teenager in Iceland, I always used to sub-vocalize [1] it as
Arootha with a thorn. I don't speak IPA so I left the fancy symbolism
out of this Usenet post.
Now the question is, what /traditions/ do English speakers use to
guess such pronunciations? It's apparently a guess if Anthony is
pronounced with a Thorn [2] or a T, based on a recent discussion in alt.usage.eng- lish. So, for fictional names like /Arutha/ -- at
least, I don't rem- ember encountering it in the real world -- what
is the hint it should be a T, and not Thurz?
[2] Actually, /Thurz/ if I remember my Elder Futhark correctly, but
the name got changed in Iceland, and forgotten in England. My guess
is something about religious intolerance against a heathen script,
which is not a valid reason not to use it today; yet the Oxford
English Diction- ary, or its editors, are lazy at picking it up again.
I believe that Norman scribes introduced th and ch into English,
ignoring the fact that English already had one-letter ways of writing
those sounds. I suspect that this was from sheer laziness. Instead of
working out how English writing worked, they tried to force French
spelling conventions onto English.
The Normans were themselves descendants of Vikings. In what seems like a
very short time, they lost their own language and adopted a dialect of French.
However, thorn and wynn were adopted into the Latin alphabet for Old
English at that time (I'm not sure why, since AFAIK the "th" and "w"
sounds were represented in Latin already;
Movable type also probably played a role here, as the print quality
was often not the greatest.
On Fri, 20 Nov 2026 11:23:43 +0800
Johann 'Myrkraverk' Oskarsson <johann@myrkraverk.invalid> wrote:
As a teenager in Iceland, I always used to sub-vocalize [1] it as
Arootha with a thorn. I don't speak IPA so I left the fancy symbolism
out of this Usenet post.
Now the question is, what /traditions/ do English speakers use to
guess such pronunciations? It's apparently a guess if Anthony is
pronounced with a Thorn [2] or a T, based on a recent discussion in
alt.usage.eng- lish. So, for fictional names like /Arutha/ -- at
least, I don't rem- ember encountering it in the real world -- what
is the hint it should be a T, and not Thurz?
Saying "Antony" for "Anthony" is mainly the case for people from a more Latinate background (i.e. Spanish, Italian, or various Latin American heritage) where the mother-tongue variant is "Antonio" or similar, at
least in US English. It's a thing you pick up on a case-by-case basis -
e.g. you're meeting someone whose name you've gotten in print, assume
it's the "standard" (thorn) reading, and then you hear it in person and
go "ah, he says it with a T."
As for characters in fantasy, the author just does whatever they want ;)
[2] Actually, /Thurz/ if I remember my Elder Futhark correctly, but
the name got changed in Iceland, and forgotten in England. My guess
is something about religious intolerance against a heathen script,
which is not a valid reason not to use it today; yet the Oxford
English Diction- ary, or its editors, are lazy at picking it up again.
I had to look this up, and from what I can tell there are a few factors
at play. Old English was originally written in runic script, and the
switch to the Latin alphabet did coincide with the Christianization of England in the 7th century (though it probably had less to do with an objection to "heathen" scripts/languages - various early Church writers
wrote in their native languages, too - than the fact that Latin was a
lingua franca for much of western Europe, courtesy of the Roman Empire
as well as the Church, and the Church's role in the promotion of
literary culture in the Middle Ages.)
However, thorn and wynn were adopted into the Latin alphabet for Old
English at that time (I'm not sure why, since AFAIK the "th" and "w"
sounds were represented in Latin already; maybe there was some peculi-
arity of local orthography back when that led scribes to use separate
letters for these, or maybe it was just quicker to write a single
character instead of a digraph.)
These survived well into Middle English (thorn in fact overtook the Latin-derived edh/eth in the 9th century,) but by the late 13th century
the shapes of the letters had mutated to the point where - as bliss was noting elsethread - if you weren't meticulous in writing them, thorn,
wynn, b, and p/P all started getting a bit indistinguishable. Movable
type also probably played a role here, as the print quality was often
not the greatest.*
* (I did not know 'til I was finally sitting down with "Beowulf" last
spring that litotes - the figure-of-speech in which a thing is stated
by denying its opposite - was a fixture of Old English humor, in more
or less this exact construction. It's neat that it remains part of the
language to this day!)
These factors led to the deprecation of thorn and wynn in favor of "th" (which was already standard in Latin) and "w" (initially a ligature of
"uu," which we got from the Normans in the 12th century.) There was
also a period where print usage substituted "Y" for thorn/th, even up
to the original printing of the King James Bible (early 17th century,)
which led to people of later centuries confusing "ye" (the nominative
case of "you," now archaic) for "ye" (a print abbreviation for "the")
and the mock-antique construction of "ye olde $FOOBAR."
However, thorn and wynn were adopted into the Latin alphabet for Old English at that time (I'm not sure why, since AFAIK the "th" and "w"
sounds were represented in Latin already;
No, the pronunciation of Latin <v> had shifted from classical [w]
to [v] at this point, and there was no [?] in Latin.
Movable type also probably played a role here, as the print quality
was often not the greatest.
William Caxton, who introduced the printing press to England, had
his start in Flanders. I remember the claim the letters were
originally imported from there, so would have lacked special English characters. (PTD used to assert this.)
Thank you. I'll add that I suspect some of the runic translations
and/ or transliterations from Old Norse to now Old Icelandic [1] are erroneous. But since the original runic manuscripts are now lost
[1], it's impossible for me to be proven right, or wrong about that.
[1] Since the manuscripts were preserved in Iceland, but Old Norse and
Old Icelandic are basically the same language, as far as I've been
personally able to tell.
I'll also add that while I haven't read Beowulf in the original -- yet
-- I've been told it's easier to read it as Icelandic rather than Eng-
lish.
Personally, I wish scholars and museums were happier about publishing
the actual source material, and not just scholarly interpretations of
it.
[vaious linguistic things]
Since the Normen (grammer?) had taken over England with military
force
These survived well into Middle English (thorn in fact overtook the Latin-derived edh/eth in the 9th century,) but by the late 13th century
the shapes of the letters had mutated to the point where - as bliss was noting elsethread - if you weren't meticulous in writing them, thorn,
wynn, b, and p/P all started getting a bit indistinguishable.
| Sysop: | Tetrazocine |
|---|---|
| Location: | Melbourne, VIC, Australia |
| Users: | 3 |
| Nodes: | 8 (0 / 8) |
| Uptime: | 46:59:56 |
| Calls: | 222 |
| Files: | 21,513 |
| Messages: | 82,318 |