• _Challenges_ Edited by David Weber

    From Robert Woodward@3:633/10 to All on Sat Nov 8 22:20:02 2025
    This is the 8th Honorverse anthology. While the cover claims that the
    stories are from the earliest days of the Star Kingdom of Manticore,
    IMHO, 2 of the 5 stories don?t qualify. However, those 2 stories do
    feature two heroes of the RMN.

    ?One Controllable Step? by Marisa Wolf(1)

    A Beowulf medical team travels to Manticore to help fight the Plague.
    They succeeded in creating a vaccine for it, though several team members
    died the disease. The Bassingford that the RMN?s chief medical center is
    named after appears. BTW, the vaccine they developed failed several
    years later when the virus mutated again.

    ?Deadly Delusions? by Jane Lindskold

    This is a prequel of ?The Stray? (which appeared in the 2nd anthology,
    _Worlds of Honor_, written by the late Linda Evans). We meet the people
    who were killed in that story in more happy times and two sisters, one
    of which had an imagination that could be described as excessive.

    ?The Great Condiment Caper? by Jacob Holo(2) with Thomas Pope

    Ensign Edward Saganami, assigned to the Stores Division of the RMN?s
    first Dreadnought, the?Ad Astra?, is ordered to help look for a missing
    pallet of barbecue sauce (600 liters worth). Since this takes place
    years after the first passage through the Manticore Junction, I don?t
    consider this to be early Star Kingdom, struggling to survive. This is a
    baby titan, growing like a weed. BTW, Ensign Saganami found the pallet
    and impressed his superior and a chief petty officer in doing so.

    ?XO? by Daniel Allen Butler

    Lt. Commander Ellen D?Orville takes command of an RMN frigate when the
    captain collapses due to a medical emergency (this takes place several
    decades after the previous story). The baby titan I referred to in the previous story is now old enough to kick ass and take names (which it
    had done several years before in Silesia). D?Orville has the opportunity
    to do some kicking and name taking herself and does so. However, this
    was in somebody else?s star system whose government was loudly annoyed
    (but several members of said government were privately thankful for her intervention).

    ?Crystal Singer?s Song? by David Weber

    This takes place a couple of decades after ?One Controllable Step?.
    Aldona (I believe that is her on the cover), a member of the Sphinx
    Forestry Service, is delivering emergency supplies during a major storm.
    Her transport is hit by a lightning bolt which took out all navigation equipment; she ended up lost over the ocean and crashing on an unnamed
    island. There she discovers a colony of treecats (note that this is
    several decades before Stephanie Harrington discovered them) - how they
    got there is a different epic of survival. She spends the rest of her
    50+ years of life there, teaching the treecats some relatively advanced techniques, such as spears and spear throwers, primitive agriculture,
    pottery wheels, and klln-firing pottery. This is contained inside an
    envelope story (3) involving Honor Harrington (said unnamed island had
    been noticed and the treecat colony contacted several years before).
    IMHO, this envelope weakens the story.

    Notes:

    1) I have heard that Marisa Wolf will be replacing the late Eric Flint
    as the co-author of the books dealing directly with the Mesan Alignment.

    2) I have heard that Jacob Holo will be writing more Edward Saganami
    stories.

    3) There is a reason why Honor was involved, but IMHO it would had been
    better as part of an epilogue. BTW, upon consideration, I find it ?
    difficult ? to accept the premise that NOBODY had visited that island
    (and it was fairly large, between Sicily and Tasmania in size) for more
    then 4 centuries after Aldona crashed there. I don?t care how close it
    is to the southern ice-cap of Sphinx. It had forests and thus was part
    of the responsibility of the Sphinx Forestry Service.

    --
    "We have advanced to new and surprising levels of bafflement."
    Imperial Auditor Miles Vorkosigan describes progress in _Komarr_. ?-----------------------------------------------------
    Robert Woodward robertaw@drizzle.com

    --- PyGate Linux v1.5
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)
  • From Lynn McGuire@3:633/10 to All on Sun Nov 9 17:49:20 2025
    On 11/9/2025 12:20 AM, Robert Woodward wrote:
    This is the 8th Honorverse anthology. While the cover claims that the
    stories are from the earliest days of the Star Kingdom of Manticore,
    IMHO, 2 of the 5 stories don?t qualify. However, those 2 stories do
    feature two heroes of the RMN.

    ?One Controllable Stepý by Marisa Wolf(1)

    A Beowulf medical team travels to Manticore to help fight the Plague.
    They succeeded in creating a vaccine for it, though several team members
    died the disease. The Bassingford that the RMN?s chief medical center is named after appears. BTW, the vaccine they developed failed several
    years later when the virus mutated again.

    ?Deadly Delusionsý by Jane Lindskold

    This is a prequel of ?The Strayý (which appeared in the 2nd anthology, _Worlds of Honor_, written by the late Linda Evans). We meet the people
    who were killed in that story in more happy times and two sisters, one
    of which had an imagination that could be described as excessive.

    ?The Great Condiment Caperý by Jacob Holo(2) with Thomas Pope

    Ensign Edward Saganami, assigned to the Stores Division of the RMN?s
    first Dreadnought, theýAd Astraý, is ordered to help look for a missing pallet of barbecue sauce (600 liters worth). Since this takes place
    years after the first passage through the Manticore Junction, I don?t consider this to be early Star Kingdom, struggling to survive. This is a
    baby titan, growing like a weed. BTW, Ensign Saganami found the pallet
    and impressed his superior and a chief petty officer in doing so.

    ?XOý by Daniel Allen Butler

    Lt. Commander Ellen D?Orville takes command of an RMN frigate when the captain collapses due to a medical emergency (this takes place several decades after the previous story). The baby titan I referred to in the previous story is now old enough to kick ass and take names (which it
    had done several years before in Silesia). D?Orville has the opportunity
    to do some kicking and name taking herself and does so. However, this
    was in somebody else?s star system whose government was loudly annoyed
    (but several members of said government were privately thankful for her intervention).

    ?Crystal Singer?s Songý by David Weber

    This takes place a couple of decades after ?One Controllable Stepý.
    Aldona (I believe that is her on the cover), a member of the Sphinx
    Forestry Service, is delivering emergency supplies during a major storm.
    Her transport is hit by a lightning bolt which took out all navigation equipment; she ended up lost over the ocean and crashing on an unnamed island. There she discovers a colony of treecats (note that this is
    several decades before Stephanie Harrington discovered them) - how they
    got there is a different epic of survival. She spends the rest of her
    50+ years of life there, teaching the treecats some relatively advanced techniques, such as spears and spear throwers, primitive agriculture,
    pottery wheels, and klln-firing pottery. This is contained inside an
    envelope story (3) involving Honor Harrington (said unnamed island had
    been noticed and the treecat colony contacted several years before).
    IMHO, this envelope weakens the story.

    Notes:

    1) I have heard that Marisa Wolf will be replacing the late Eric Flint
    as the co-author of the books dealing directly with the Mesan Alignment.

    2) I have heard that Jacob Holo will be writing more Edward Saganami
    stories.

    3) There is a reason why Honor was involved, but IMHO it would had been better as part of an epilogue. BTW, upon consideration, I find it ? difficult ? to accept the premise that NOBODY had visited that island
    (and it was fairly large, between Sicily and Tasmania in size) for more
    then 4 centuries after Aldona crashed there. I don?t care how close it
    is to the southern ice-cap of Sphinx. It had forests and thus was part
    of the responsibility of the Sphinx Forestry Service.


    https://www.amazon.com/Challenges-Worlds-Honor-Weber-David/dp/1668072955/

    3 stars, 4 stars, or 5 stars ?

    Lynn


    --- PyGate Linux v1.5
    * Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)