AI/LLM Reviews of Star Trek The Next Generation - Bonding

ChatGPT

Alright — let’s look at **“Star Trek:
The Next Generation” — *The Bonding*** using
the script from [chakoteya.net]
(http://www.chakoteya.net/NextGen/153.htm).

- ---

**Episode:** *The Bonding*
**Season:** 3, Episode 5
**Original Air Date:** October 23, 1989
**Writer:** Ronald D. Moore’s
first TNG script (a big milestone!)

- ---

## 📋 **Summary (from the transcript)**

During an archaeological mission on a planet
once occupied by an ancient alien race called
the Koinonians, a crew member — Marla Aster — is
killed by a leftover mine. She leaves behind
her young son, Jeremy.

Worf, who led the mission, feels deeply
responsible for her death. He wants to perform
a Klingon ritual of bonding with Jeremy — giving
the orphan a new family and spiritual protection
in the Klingon tradition. But Jeremy is grieving
and doesn’t understand Klingon
customs — or why his mother died.

Meanwhile, a Koinonian alien presence manifests
as a perfect illusion of Marla Aster. It tries
to comfort Jeremy and take him away to live
with her on the surface — a fantasy life
where he won’t feel pain again. Picard, Troi,
and Worf must help Jeremy confront his grief
instead of running from it. In the end, Jeremy
chooses to stay on the Enterprise, face his loss,
and accept Worf’s Klingon bonding ritual
as a new beginning.

- ---

## ✅ **Strengths**

**➊ A sensitive look at grief:** *The Bonding*
was TNG’s first real attempt to tackle a child’s
grief in a meaningful way. It shows Starfleet’s
dangers without cheap heroics: sometimes people
die for no grand reason.

**➋ Worf’s depth:** This is an important Worf
episode. It expands his culture
and values — honour, responsibility, and how
he tries to bridge his Klingon traditions
with human customs.

**➌ Picard’s quiet wisdom:** Picard’s speech
about how children shouldn’t be aboard starships
but how it’s part of Starfleet’s reality
is classic TNG honesty.

**� Subtle sci-fi element:** The Koinonian
alien is simple but thematically strong — it’s
not malevolent, just misguided in trying
to spare Jeremy pain.

**➎ Ronald D. Moore’s style:** You can see
the seeds of the more mature, character-driven
Trek stories he’d later deliver.

- ---

## ❌ **Weaknesses**

**➊ A bit low-key:** The plot is more emotional
than sci-fi heavy, so it can feel slow if you’re
expecting big stakes.

**➋ Jeremy is a bit flat:** He’s believable
enough, but not a standout child performance.

**➌ The Koinonian alien is underdeveloped:** The
episode hints at a mysterious ancient race but
never explores it — it’s really just a vehicle
for the grief plot.

- ---

## 🎭 **Standout moments**

* Worf telling Jeremy about the Klingon
bonding ritual — solemn and sincere.

* Picard explaining to Troi why he struggles
with children aboard his ship.

* The final scene of the ritual — quiet but moving.

- ---

## 🗨️ **Best line**

**Picard:** *“If you could avoid

all loss, would you?”*

That idea — that grief is an unavoidable
part of life worth facing — is the episode’s
whole point.

- ---

## ⭐ **Rating: 7/10**

**Verdict:** *The Bonding* is a thoughtful,
understated episode — important for fleshing
out Worf and showing that Starfleet’s utopian
ideals don’t erase tragedy. It’s not one of
the season’s most thrilling hours, but it’s
heartfelt, respectful, and lays the groundwork
for the deeper, more mature TNG stories
that Season 3 would keep delivering.
A quiet but valuable entry.

Google Gemini

"Star Trek: The Next Generation - Bonding" is
a touching and emotionally driven episode that
explores themes of grief, loss, the nature
of mourning, and the unique ways individuals
cope with tragedy. It centers on the Enterprise
crew's efforts to help a child deal
with the death of a parent.

Plot Overview:

The episode begins with a tragic
accident: Lieutenant Marla Aster,
a ship's archaeologist, is killed during
an away mission, leaving behind her orphaned
young son, Jeremy. Captain Picard
and the Enterprise crew are faced
with the difficult task of dealing
with the emotional fallout, particularly
for Jeremy, who is struggling profoundly
with his mother's sudden death.

The crew investigates the cause of the accident,
discovering that it was the result of
an explosive device left over from a past war,
adding a layer of senselessness to the tragedy.
Meanwhile, Jeremy isolates himself in his grief.
Counselor Troi and Lieutenant Worf both attempt
to help him cope, with Worf offering a unique
perspective through a Klingon bonding ritual,
which provides Jeremy with a structured way
to process his emotions.

As Jeremy grapples with his overwhelming loss,
a mysterious energy field from the planet where
his mother died manifests as a holographic,
seemingly sentient version of Marla Aster.
This entity attempts to take Jeremy away,
promising to reunite him with his mother.
Captain Picard and the crew must then
delicately, yet firmly, convince Jeremy
that this is not his real mother, and that
he needs to confront and accept his grief
in order to truly heal. Wesley Crusher,
who experienced a similar loss with his
own father, shares his feelings
and provides a relatable perspective
to Jeremy. Ultimately, Jeremy accepts
the truth, and the energy being, having
served its purpose or perhaps realising
its error, dissipates, allowing Jeremy
to begin his genuine grieving process.

Strengths:

Emotional Depth and Sensitivity: The episode
handles the difficult subject of a child's
grief with remarkable sensitivity and nuance.
It's a genuinely moving portrayal of loss
and healing.

Worf's Character Development: Worf's interaction
with Jeremy and his sharing of Klingon mourning
rituals are a significant highlight. It showcases
a compassionate, paternal side to Worf that
deepens his character beyond just a warrior.

Wesley's Empathy: Wesley's ability to connect
with Jeremy through his own experience of loss
is a strong point, making his character
more relatable and empathetic.

Exploration of Grief: The episode effectively
explores different facets of grief, from denial
and anger to the eventual acceptance,
and the importance of healthy coping mechanisms.

Picard's Compassion: Captain Picard's thoughtful
and gentle approach to Jeremy's situation,
balancing his duty with genuine concern,
is a testament to his leadership.

Weaknesses:

The Energy Being: The mysterious energy being
that manifests as Marla Aster, while a catalyst
for the emotional plot, feels somewhat
underdeveloped as a sci-fi concept.
Its motivations and nature are not deeply
explored beyond its role in Jeremy's grief.

Pacing (Minor): The episode's focus on emotional
processing means it's less action-driven,
and some viewers might find the pacing
a bit slow at times.

Convenient Resolution: The energy being's
convenient dissipation once Jeremy accepts
the truth, while emotionally satisfying,
feels a bit too neat for a complex alien
phenomenon.

Dated Visuals: As an early TNG episode,
some of the visual effects for the energy
being and the holographic manifestations
show their age.

Overall Impression:

"Bonding" is a heartfelt and emotionally
resonant episode of Star Trek: The Next
Generation. It excels in its sensitive
portrayal of grief and loss, and provides
significant, touching character development
for Worf and Wesley. While the sci-fi element
of the energy being is somewhat simplistic,
the episode's strong emotional core
and its focus on the human (and Klingon)
experience of mourning make it a memorable
and impactful entry in the series.

Rating: 7.8/10
--
Member - Liberal International This is doctor@nk.ca Ici doctor@nk.ca
Yahweh, King & country!Never Satan President Republic!Beware AntiChrist rising! Look at Psalms 14 and 53 on Atheism ;
All I want to hear from JEsus Christ is WEll done Good and Faithful servant

--- MBSE BBS v1.1.2 (Linux-x86_64)
* Origin: NetKnow News (3:633/280.2@fidonet)