AI / LLM reviews of STNG - The Dauphin

Google Gemini

"Star Trek: The Next Generation - The Dauphin"
is an episode that focuses on Wesley Crusher's
first romantic encounter, set against a backdrop
of alien diplomacy and the revelation
of a surprising alien biology.

Plot Overview:The USS Enterprise-D is dispatched
to pick up Salia, a young woman whose destiny is
to unite the long-warring factions of her home
planet, Daled IV. Salia and her enigmatic governess,
Anya, are brought aboard the Enterprise.
Ensign Wesley Crusher, still grappling
with his adolescence, quickly becomes infatuated
with Salia, leading to a budding, innocent romance.
However, Counselor Troi senses that both Salia
and Anya are not entirely what they seem,
detecting hidden complexities beneath their
human-like exteriors.

It is soon revealed that Anya is an "allasomorph,"
a powerful shapeshifter capable of transforming
into various life forms, and she is fiercely,
almost violently, protective of Salia.
Wesley and Salia spend time together, exploring
their feelings and the wonders of the holodeck.
Their burgeoning romance is abruptly cut short
when Anya, in her protective zeal, violently
attacks Wesley. This incident forces Salia
to reveal her true nature: she, too, is
an allasomorph, capable of transformation,
and her true form is not humanoid.
The Enterprise eventually arrives at Daled IV,
and Salia prepares to fulfill her destiny
as a peacemaker. Anya departs, leaving Salia
to share a poignant goodbye with Wesley,
who has experienced his first taste of love and loss.

Strengths:

Wesley's Romantic Arc: The episode
provides a significant coming-of-age moment
for Wesley Crusher, exploring his first
romantic attraction and the emotional
complexities that come with it. It's a relatable
experience for many viewers.

Allasomorph Concept: The idea of the allasomorphs,
powerful shapeshifters, is an intriguing alien
concept, adding a layer of mystery and wonder
to the characters of Salia and Anya.

Troi's Intuition: Counselor Troi's empathic
abilities are used effectively to hint at the
true nature of Salia and Anya, building suspense.

Themes of Duty vs. Desire: Salia's struggle
between her personal feelings for Wesley
and her destiny to unite her people is
a classic Star Trek dilemma.

Weaknesses:

Anya's Over-Protectiveness: Anya's extreme,
almost violent, protectiveness of Salia
can feel over-the-top and sometimes undermines
the more nuanced aspects of the story.
Her actions are often more aggressive than necessary.

Pacing: The episode's pacing can feel a bit slow,
particularly in the early stages of Wesley
and Salia's romance, before the true nature
of the allasomorphs is revealed.

Dated Visuals: As an early TNG episode,
the visual effects for the allasomorph
transformations and some of the alien
forms show their age.

Simplistic Resolution: The resolution
of Salia fulfilling her destiny, while
emotionally impactful for Wesley, feels
somewhat simplistic in terms of the broader
political conflict on Daled IV.

Wesley's Character (Polarizing): For viewers
who already found Wesley Crusher a challenging
character, an episode centered on his first
romance might not have been appealing.

Overall Impression:"The Dauphin" is a notable
early Star Trek: The Next Generation episode
for its focus on Wesley Crusher's personal
growth and its introduction of the intriguing
allasomorph species. While it has some pacing
issues, dated visuals, and an antagonist whose
actions can feel exaggerated, its exploration
of young love, destiny, and the mysteries
of alien biology make it a memorable, if not
universally beloved, entry in the series.

Rating: 5.5/10

ChapGPT

Alright — let’s break down
**“Star Trek: The Next Generation” — *The Dauphin***
using the transcript from [chakoteya.net] (http://www.chakoteya.net/NextGen/136.htm).

- ---

**Episode:** *The Dauphin*
**Season:** 2, Episode 10
**Original Air Date:** February 20, 1989

- ---

### **Summary (based on the transcript)**

The Enterprise is tasked with transporting
Salia, a young ruler destined to unify
the war-torn planet Daled IV. Salia has
lived her life in isolation, protected
by her fiercely devoted governess Anya.
While on board, Wesley Crusher falls
instantly in love with Salia, who’s
equally fascinated by Wesley and his world.
But there’s a twist: Salia and Anya are
both shapeshifters — allasomorphs — able
to change their physical form. Anya is
overprotective and threatening to the
crew if she senses danger to Salia.
Wesley struggles to reconcile his feelings
for Salia once he learns she’s not human,
and Salia ultimately must leave him behind
to fulfill her destiny.

- ---

### **Strengths:**

✅ **A sincere coming-of-age story:** The
core idea — Wesley experiencing first love
and heartbreak — is relatable and sweet.
It’s a nice window into Wesley as a teenager
with real vulnerabilities,
not just the ship’s boy genius.

✅ **World-building:** The concept
of the allasomorph shapeshifters is intriguing,
even if underexplored. Salia’s role as the sole
hope for her divided planet gives the story
an air of bittersweet responsibility.

✅ **Character beats:** Worf’s moment explaining
Klingon courtship rituals is genuinely funny
and very “Worf.” Guinan and Riker’s playful
flirt demonstration in Ten Forward is also charming.

- ---

### **Weaknesses:**

❌ **Low stakes:** The episode is a pretty
lightweight teen romance — sweet, but never
feels important in the larger Trek narrative.
The “love story” resolves predictably
and doesn’t deepen the main characters
beyond surface level.

❌ **The creature effects:** The allasomorph
transformations look dated and awkward even
by late 80s Trek standards. The bear-like
monster Anya turns into is more goofy
than threatening.

❌ **Flat ending:** The goodbye between
Wesley and Salia is touching,
but the episode doesn’t dig deep
into the consequences for either of them
or the political backdrop. Salia’s people
remain off-screen, so her great destiny
feels abstract.

- ---

### **Standout line:**

* **Guinan (to Wesley):**
*“When a man and a woman are in love,
they talk and they laugh and they share
things they never even knew they had.”*

* A simple but nice bit of Guinan wisdom
about intimacy — far more mature
than Wesley’s wide-eyed puppy love.

- ---

### **Rating: 5/10**

*The Dauphin* is a gentle, well-meaning
but ultimately minor episode. It works
as a sweet teen romance and gives Wesley
a needed human side, but the sci-fi
elements are undercooked
and the tension is minimal. It’s harmless
and watchable but not one you’d call
essential Trek.

- ---

**Final word:** If you enjoy lighter
episodes about first love and teen
awkwardness, it’s pleasant enough.
But compared to heavier TNG
standouts — like *The Measure of a Man*
or *A Matter of Honor* — it’s just
a soft filler between stronger outings.

--
Member - Liberal International This is doctor@nk.ca Ici doctor@nk.ca
Yahweh, King & country!Never Satan President Republic!Beware AntiChrist rising! Look at Psalms 14 and 53 on Atheism ;
All I want to hear from JEsus Christ is WEll done Good and Faithful servant

--- MBSE BBS v1.1.2 (Linux-x86_64)
* Origin: NetKnow News (3:633/280.2@fidonet)