Ai/LLM reviews of STNG- Loud as a whisper

google Gemini

"Star Trek: The Next Generation - Loud
as a Whisper" is a unique and thought-provoking
episode that delves into themes of communication,
disability, and the power of empathy. It introduces
a compelling guest character and explores how
overcoming personal challenges can
lead to innovative solutions.

Plot Overview:

The USS Enterprise-D is tasked with a crucial
diplomatic mission: transporting a renowned
mediator named Riva to the Ramatis star system
to resolve a centuries-old, deeply entrenched
planetary conflict on Solais Five. Upon beaming
down to meet him, Captain Picard and his away
team make a surprising discovery: Riva is deaf
and communicates through an extraordinary
"Chorus" of three individuals (the Scholar,
Adonis, and a Woman) who telepathically
interpret his thoughts, emotions, and intentions.
Each member of the Chorus represents a facet
of Riva's complex personality – intellect, passion,
and harmony.

During the initial interactions, Lieutenant La Forge,
who uses a VISOR to see, finds an unexpected common
ground with Riva, recognizing the parallel between
Riva's reliance on his Chorus and his own dependence
on technology to perceive the world. This moment
highlights the episode's central idea of turning
a perceived disadvantage into a unique strength.
As the peace conference on Solais Five begins,
tragedy strikes: an assassin, representing
one of the warring factions, brutally kills
Riva's entire Chorus, leaving him isolated
and unable to communicate. Riva becomes
withdrawn, frightened, and traditional
medical interventions prove useless.

Counsellor Troi and Data attempt to help
Riva overcome his profound loss. Data
diligently learns various gestural languages
to establish basic communication,
while Troi gently encourages Riva to embrace
his "disability" and use it as an advantage.
Ultimately, Riva experiences a profound shift.
He decides to return to Solais Five alone,
not as a conventional mediator, but as a teacher.
His new approach is to teach the warring factions
sign language, believing that by learning to
communicate directly with him in a new way,
they will also learn to communicate more
effectively and empathetically with each other,
fostering genuine peace. The episode concludes
with Riva beginning this arduous but hopeful
process, as the Enterprise departs, confident
in his unconventional yet powerful
new method of mediation.

Strengths:

Unique Premise and Character: Riva is a truly unique
and memorable guest character. His method
of communication and his journey through grief
and rediscovery are compelling.

Theme of Communication: The episode brilliantly
explores various facets of communication – verbal,
non-verbal, empathic, and the challenges of misunderstanding.

Portrayal of Disability: It offers a thoughtful
and respectful portrayal of deafness, focusing
on adaptation and unique abilities rather than
just limitations. The parallel with La Forge
is particularly strong.

Picard's Empathy: Captain Picard demonstrates
exceptional empathy and patience in his
interactions with Riva, highlighting
his compassionate leadership.

Data's Learning: Data's immediate and practical
response to Riva's communication challenge
(learning sign languages) showcases his
problem-solving skills and desire to understand.

Powerful Resolution: Riva's decision to teach sign
language as a means to peace is a truly insightful
and moving resolution, reinforcing Star Trek's core
message of finding common ground.

Weaknesses:

Pacing (Minor): The initial setup and the "Chorus"
explanation might feel a little slow for some viewers
before the central conflict and Riva's personal journey
fully take hold.

The "Chorus" Concept: While unique, the Chorus
as a plot device could be seen as somewhat fantastical,
even for Star Trek, making the setup a bit less grounded
initially.

Limited Conflict on Solais Five: The warring factions
on Solais Five are not deeply developed, serving mostly
as a backdrop for Riva's mediation. The assassin's action,
while impactful, feels somewhat abrupt.

Visuals: As an early TNG episode, some of the visual
effects and set designs show their age.

Overall Impression:"Loud as a Whisper"
is a powerful, insightful, and emotionally
resonant episode of Star Trek: The Next Generation.
It stands out for its unique central character,
its thoughtful exploration of communication
and disability, and its ultimately hopeful message
about finding new ways to bridge divides. Despite
some minor pacing issues and early-season visual limitations,
it is a highly recommended and significant entry
in the series, showcasing TNG's ability to tell
humanistic and philosophical stories.

Rating: 8.2/10

ChatGpt

Here’s a refined review of **“Loud as a Whisper”**
(TNG S2E5), grounding the analysis in the chakoteya
transcript and extensive commentary:

- ---

## 🌟 Premise & Innovative Concept

The Enterprise transports **Riva**, a deaf mediator
who communicates through a three-person telepathic
*chorus* representing facets of his soul
(**passion**, **logic**, **wisdom**).
This unusual setup is abruptly shattered
when assassins kill his chorus, forcing
Picard, Troi, and Data to find new ways
for him to communicate. ([filmscoremonthly.com][1])

- ---

## � Strengths

* **Authentic Representation & Bold Casting**
Casting deaf actor Howie Seago brought rare
1980s authenticity. Seago advocated for
key changes—like having Data learn sign
language rather than making Riva
speak—which enhanced representation
and narrative power ([reddit.com][2], [screenrant.com][3]).

* **Powerful Emotional Core**
The shock of the chorus’s violent death
is deeply affecting—Riker even cries
out—disturbing in a way that the usually
controlled TNG rarely achieves ([markwatches.net][4]).

* **Thought-Provoking Themes**
Communication barriers, disability,
and empowering differences are central
and admirable. The idea that disadvantage
can become strength resonates, supported
by both Seago and critics ([filmscoremonthly.com][1], [addictedtostartrek.blogspot.com][5]).

- ---

## ⚠️ Weaknesses

* **Pacing and Structural Gaps**
Critics note it's slow-moving, with
a drawn-out first act, and an odd,
underdeveloped subplot (Geordi’s eye surgery)
that never reaches resolution ([markwatches.net][4]).

* **Clumsy Execution**
Some argue the episode grows muddled—characters
speak directly to the interpreters, contradictory
to best communication practices, and the chorus
conceit isn't fully contextualized ([trakt.tv][6]).

* **Mixed Critical Responses**
While The A.V. Club gives it a **B–**, calling
it “painfully earnest” yet inspiring, Tor.com
rated it **4/10**, citing both earnestness
and execution flaws ([filmscoremonthly.com][1], [en.wikipedia.org][7]).

- ---

## 👥 Community & Fan Insights

* **Reddit** users validate its impact
on disability representation, story authenticity,
and emotional resonance—even if the ending is modest and flawed .

* One advises caution:

“Picard grabbing Riva’s head and shouting in
his face really hasn’t aged well” ([reddit.com][8]).

- ---

## 🎯 Verdict & Rating — **7 / 10**

**What works:**

* A rare, provocative representation of deafness and communication.
* Strong performances—especially from Seago and Spiner.
* Emotional impact that feels genuinely earned.

**What falls short:**

* Slow pacing and an unresolved subplot weaken narrative momentum.
* Some writing choices clash with the progressive goals.
* Critics point out that its passion occasionally clashes with subtlety.

**Final Take:**
“Loud as a Whisper” stands as a courageous, empathetic
meditation on communication and difference—anchored by
convincing performances and thoughtful casting.
Though imperfect in execution, its core message
and authenticity bring it close to TNG’s
best character-driven episodes.

**My rating: 7 / 10**


[1]: https://www.filmscoremonthly.com/notes/box05_disc05.html?utm_source=chatgpt.com "FSM: \"Where Silence Has Lease,\" \"The Outrageous Okona,\" \"Loud as a Whisper\" (Ron Jones)"
[2]:
https://www.reddit.com/r/deaf/comments/ynendo?utm_source=chatgpt.com "A
hearing Trekie with questions."
[3]: https://screenrant.com/star-trek-tng-deaf-guest-star-episode-better/?utm_source=chatgpt.com "Deaf Star Trek TNG Guest Star Made Their Episode's Ending
Better"
[4]: https://markwatches.net/reviews/2015/05/mark-watches-the-next-generation-s02e05-loud-as-a-whisper/?utm_source=chatgpt.com "Mark Watches ‘The Next
Generation’: S02E05 – Loud as a Whisper |"
[5]: https://addictedtostartrek.blogspot.com/2018/03/episode-review-loud-as-whisper-next.html?utm_source=chatgpt.com "Addicted to Star Trek: Episode Review -
Loud as a Whisper (Next Generation, Season 2)"
[6]: https://trakt.tv/comments/354870?utm_source=chatgpt.com "Star Trek:
The Next Generation 2x05 \"Loud as a Whisper\" review by Andrew Bloom -
Trakt"
[7]:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loud_as_a_Whisper?utm_source=chatgpt.com
"Loud as a Whisper"
[8]: https://www.reddit.com/r/StarTrekViewingParty/comments/1ia7dbg?utm_source=chatgpt.com "TNG, Episode 2x5, Loud As A Whisper"
--
Member - Liberal International This is doctor@nk.ca Ici doctor@nk.ca
Yahweh, King & country!Never Satan President Republic!Beware AntiChrist rising! Look at Psalms 14 and 53 on Atheism ;
All I want to hear from JEsus Christ is WEll done Good and Faithful servant

--- MBSE BBS v1.1.2 (Linux-x86_64)
* Origin: NetKnow News (3:633/280.2@fidonet)