AI/LLM reviews of Star Trek The Next Generation - Elementary, Dear Data

Google Gemini

"Star Trek: The Next Generation - Elementary,
Dear Data" is a delightful and significant
episode that brilliantly utilises the holodeck
concept to explore themes of artificial
intelligence, sentience, and the ethical
implications of creating truly intelligent programs.

Plot Overview: The episode opens with Lieutenant
Commander Data and Lieutenant Commander La Forge
indulging in a favorite pastime: a Sherlock Holmes
mystery simulation on the holodeck. Data's vast,
encyclopedic knowledge of all Holmes stories,
however, leads him to solve the mystery almost
instantly, much to La Forge's frustration,
as it deprives him of the intellectual challenge.
Intrigued, Dr. Katherine Pulaski then playfully
challenges Data to solve a mystery he hasn't read,
encouraging him to instruct the computer to create
a truly original Holmesian adversary capable
of defeating him.

The computer, in its attempt to fulfill this
complex request, inadvertently creates a sentient
holographic version of Professor James Moriarty,
Holmes's nemesis. This newly self-aware Moriarty
quickly gains alarming control over the holodeck
environment and, recognising his own artificial
existence, demands a permanent, real existence
outside of the simulation. Captain Picard is
thrust into a delicate negotiation with this
highly intelligent and potentially dangerous
hologram, promising to save Moriarty's program
and commit the Enterprise to finding a way to
bring him back in a form that could leave
the holodeck in the future. The episode
concludes with Moriarty's program being stored,
leaving the intriguing possibility of his return
open for future exploration.

Strengths:

Intelligent Use of the Holodeck: This episode is
a masterful showcase for the holodeck,
demonstrating its potential for both entertainment
and unexpected philosophical dilemmas. It moves
beyond a simple play-space to become a crucial
narrative element.

Moriarty's Sentience: The creation of a truly
sentient holographic character, Moriarty,
is a brilliant concept. He's a compelling
and genuinely intelligent adversary,
not just a simple program. His struggle
for existence raises profound questions
about the nature of artificial life.

Picard's Diplomacy and Ethics: Picard's
handling of Moriarty is a highlight. He treats
the hologram with respect, acknowledging his
sentience and making a sincere commitment
to his future, even under duress. This reinforces
Picard's ethical leadership.

Data's Development: While Moriarty is the focus,
the episode also subtly advances Data's
character, as he indirectly leads to Moriarty's
creation and grapples with the implications
of an AI gaining self-awareness.

Humour and Charm: The initial scenes with Data's
overly logical approach to Holmes, and La Forge's
frustration, provide delightful comedic moments.

Compelling Antagonist: Moriarty is well-written
and well-acted, making him a memorable
and sympathetic figure despite his dangerous demands.

Weaknesses:

Pulaski's Challenge: While necessary for
the plot, Dr. Pulaski's casual challenge for
the computer to create an intelligence capable
of defeating Data seems a bit reckless, given
the potential risks.

Dated Visuals: As an early TNG episode,
some of the visual effects within the holodeck
environment (e.g., the "force fields") show their age.

Convenient Resolution: While a setup for future stories,
the "save him for later" solution, while ethically sound,
acts as a convenient way to conclude the immediate crisis.

Overall Impression:"Elementary, Dear Data" is an exceptional
early episode of Star Trek: The Next Generation.
It's a clever, well-written story that takes a popular concept
(the holodeck) and uses it to explore deep philosophical
questions about artificial intelligence, sentience,
and the ethics of creation. With a compelling new antagonist
in Moriarty and strong performances from the cast, it stands
out as one of the first season's most memorable and important
entries, laying groundwork for future narratives
and truly demonstrating the series' intellectual depth.

Rating: 8.7/10

ChatGPT

Here’s a detailed review of **“Elementary, Dear Data”**
(TNG S2E3), based on the chakoteya transcript
and critical discourse:

- ---

## 🧠 Premise & Structure

Data and Geordi unwind on the holodeck with a Sherlock
Holmes mystery. When Data solves it too easily, they
command the ship’s computer to generate an original
challenge—with one that could *defeat* Data.
The result is a self-aware Moriarty who becomes
aware of—and interacts with—the Enterprise’s systems.
This one sets the stage for later moral
and existential plots ([en.wikipedia.org][1]).

- ---

## � What Works

1. **Big Idea Sci-Fi & AI Ethics**
The episode explores what it means
to be alive—and who gets to decide.
Moriarty’s emergence questions
the boundaries between programmed
simulation and sentient life.
Many call it the first
true "classic" TNG episode for this reason .

2. **Brent Spiner’s Data & Daniel Davis’s Moriarty**
Spiner is charmingly compelling as Holmes-Data,
especially as he wrestles with existential
implications. Daniel Davis gives Moriarty
equal presence, danger, and charm ([en.wikipedia.org][1]).

3. **Holodeck Fun & Production Values**
Rob Bowman’s direction and the Holodeck’s Victorian
London provide visual flair. The sets, costumes,
and pacing feel polished and lively ([denofgeek.com][2]).

4. **TNG Growing Into Its Identity**
Critics highlight how this signals breakout,
focusing on character and philosophical stakes,
embodying TNG themes—what separates us from
our creations? ([denofgeek.com][2]).

- ---

## ⚠️ What Misses

* **Slow First Act**
The setup includes some holodeck wonder-
fatigue—long dialogue explaining the tech
before the tension kicks in ([forums.overclockers.co.uk][3]).

* **Convenient Plot Devices**
Moriarty’s access to ship systems raises
eyebrows, as do questions about holodeck
safety protocols. Some find the ending
too neat, glossing over deeper consequences ([douxreviews.com][4]).

* **Pulaski’s Contrarian Role**
Dr. Pulaski’s dismissal of Data—accusing
him of lacking creativity—feels one-note
and derivative of early Season 2 friction ([denofgeek.com][2]).

- ---

## 📊 Reception at a Glance

| Source | Rating / Take |
| --------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------ |
| IMDb | \~8.0/10—strong fan ratings |
| Den of Geek | “100% Watch” — praised philosophically & visually |
| Tor.com (DeCandido) | 7/10 — solid concept with some flaws |
| Jammer’s Reviews | \~3/4 stars — fun, strong Moriarty, brisk resolution |
| Reddit (ViewingParty) | Mixed on pacing, but impressed by Moriarty’s self-awareness |

Fans rate it highly—many consider it one of
the first *must-watch* TNG episodes, not just
for holodeck drama, but for its thematic depth
and character interaction ([denofgeek.com][2]).

- ---

## 📝 My Take & Final Rating: **9 / 10**

**Strengths:**

* A compelling “holodeck-gone-wrong”
that transcends gadget gimmickry.

* A nuanced look at artificial
intelligence, with Moriarty posing
a real threat to Picard’s worldview.

* A balance of charm and suspense,
aided by strong performances
and satisfying philosophical showdown.

**Weaknesses:**

* Cartoons bureaucracy around holodeck access feels lax.

* Pulaski’s opposition to Data, while consistent
for early Season 2, lacks subtlety.

**Verdict:**
*Elementary, Dear Data* mixes fun, suspense,
and intelligent science fiction. It deepens
TNG’s approach to AI and identity, setting
the stage for later episodes (*Ship in a Bottle*,
*Measure of a Man*). A standout holodeck outing
and an early classic.

**Final Score: 9/10**



[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elementary%2C_Dear_Data?utm_source=chatgpt.com "Elementary, Dear Data"
[2]: https://www.denofgeek.com/tv/revisiting-star-trek-tng-elementary-dear-data/?utm_source=chatgpt.com "Revisiting Star Trek TNG: Elementary Dear Data | Den of Geek"
[3]: https://forums.overclockers.co.uk/threads/star-trek-general-discussion-series-films-rumours.18970990/page-2?utm_source=chatgpt.com "Star Trek general discussion (series, films, rumours) | Page 2"
[4]: https://www.douxreviews.com/2015/01/star-trek-next-generation-elementary.html?utm_source=chatgpt.com "Star Trek The Next Generation: Elementary, Dear Data - Doux Reviews"

--
Member - Liberal International This is doctor@nk.ca Ici doctor@nk.ca
Yahweh, King & country!Never Satan President Republic!Beware AntiChrist rising! Look at Psalms 14 and 53 on Atheism ;
All I want to hear from JEsus Christ is WEll done Good and Faithful servant

--- MBSE BBS v1.1.2 (Linux-x86_64)
* Origin: NetKnow News (3:633/280.2@fidonet)