AI/ LLM reviews of STNG - DataLore

Google Gemini

"Star Trek: The Next Generation - Datalore"
is a pivotal early episode that delves deeply
into the origins of Lieutenant Commander Data,
introducing a crucial element of his past
and a formidable antagonist who would return
to vex the Enterprise-D crew.

Plot Overview:
The USS Enterprise-D embarks on a mission
to Omicron Theta, Data's enigmatic home planet,
with the hope of uncovering the mysteries
surrounding his creation. Upon arrival,
the crew is met with a perplexing sight:
a lifeless, desolate world, starkly
contrasting with Data's warm memories
of a thriving colony. Their investigation
leads them to a hidden, underground laboratory,
the sanctuary where the brilliant Dr. Noonien
Soong brought Data into existence.

Inside the abandoned lab, they discover
a disassembled android. Upon reassembly,
this new android is revealed to be Data's
older brother, Lore. Lore, initially
charming and seemingly helpful, provides
chilling insights into the colony's
destruction, attributing it to a mysterious
crystalline entity. However, Lore's true,
malevolent nature quickly emerges.
He cunningly manipulates the crew, subtly asserting
his influence, and begins to communicate
with the crystalline entity, planning to betray
the Enterprise and offer its life force
as the entity's next meal. Data and the crew
eventually uncover Lore's insidious deception,
leading to a desperate confrontation.
In a climactic struggle, Lore is finally beamed
into space, leaving Data to grapple with
the complex, often painful, revelations about
his origins and the existence of his dangerous,
unhinged brother.

Strengths:

Data's Origins and Character Depth: This episode
is monumental for Data's character.
It explores his creation, his "parentage,"
and the crucial revelation of his brother,
Lore. This adds significant depth and pathos
to Data's quest for humanity.

Introduction of Lore: Brent Spiner's dual
performance as Data and the insidious
Lore is a standout. Lore is immediately
established as a compelling and genuinely
menacing villain, providing a perfect foil
to Data's aspiring humanity.

Philosophical Questions: The episode
raises fascinating questions about
artificial intelligence, consciousness,
free will, and the very definition of "life."

Tension and Suspense: Lore's subtle manipulation
and the increasing danger posed by the crystalline
entity build genuine tension throughout the episode.

Brent Spiner's Performance: Spiner's ability
to create two distinct and believable android
personalities is remarkable and drives much
of the episode's success.

Weaknesses:Pacing: While the tension builds,
the initial discovery and reassembly of Lore
can feel a bit slow before the full scope
of his villainy is revealed.

Crystalline Entity's Role: The crystalline entity,
while a visually interesting threat, serves more
as a plot device for Lore's machinations rather
than a fully developed antagonist itself.
Its abilities and motivations remain somewhat vague.

Convenient Escape: The method by which Lore
is ultimately defeated and beamed into space,
while logical within the episode's context,
can feel a bit too convenient
for such a powerful threat.

Dated Visuals: As an early TNG episode, some of
the visual effects, particularly the crystalline
entity and the surface of Omicron Theta, show their age.

Overall Impression:"Datalore" is a crucial
and highly memorable early episode for Star Trek: The Next Generation.
Its deep dive into Data's origins and the brilliant introduction
of Lore elevate it above many of its early series contemporaries.
While it has some minor pacing and visual limitations,
the episode's strong character work, philosophical questions,
and Brent Spiner's exceptional performance make it an essential
and highly engaging watch for any fan of the series.

Rating: 8/10

ChatGPT

**Review: *Star Trek: The Next Generation – “Datalore”***
**Season 1, Episode 13**
**Transcript Source:** chakoteya.net
**Rating:** ★★★☆☆☆☆☆☆☆ (3/10)

- ---

### **Overview**

“Datalore” marks a pivotal moment in TNG’s
early trajectory, exploring Data’s origins
and introducing his sinister counterpart,
Lore. The crew uncovers Lore’s plot
to harness the Crystalline Entity—an alien
lifeform—as a tool for destruction. While
the premise teems with potential,
the episode stumbles in pacing, logic,
and character consistency ([en.wikipedia.org][1]).

- ---

### **Highlights**

#### **1. Data & Lore Dual Performance**

Brent Spiner delivers a masterful double act,
distinguishing the gentle innocence of Data
from the malevolent sophistication of Lore.
His ability to inhabit two distinct personas
elevates the material, offering a performance
that remains compelling long after the plot fizzles .

#### **2. Origin World & Android Lore**

The episode expands TNG’s mythology with a world
steeped in Soong’s legacy and hints at mass-produced
androids—a rich vein for future exploration.
The eerie, silent planet and abandoned lab
provide atmosphere and intrigue ([them0vieblog.com][2]).

#### **3. Introduction of the Crystalline Entity**

Lore’s contact with this enigmatic creature sets up
a powerful adversary for the series. The entity is
visually striking and conceptually menacing—a rare
fully alien force that feels authentically chilling ([denofgeek.com][3]).

- ---

### **Issues**

#### **1. Illogical Crew Behavior**

Plot convenience overdrive: despite Wayne’s curse
of obvious clues, only Wesley recognizes Lore
as impostor—even Picard falls prey. Viewers groan
as characters overlook glaring inconsistencies,
weakening narrative tension ([them0vieblog.com][2]).

#### **2. Pacing & Plot Holes**

After a strong opening, the middle bogs down.
Lore’s motivations are sketched too thin;
the Crystalline Entity’s sudden appearance
feels abrupt, and the resolution—beam him
into space—resolves nothing and seems
contradictory to established Federation
values ([sagaofthejasonite.wordpress.com][4]).

#### **3. Wesley-Centric Detection**

Relying on Wesley's insight while sidelining
seasoned officers feels uninspired. This trope
undermines the senior cast and strains credibility,
making the plot feel contrived and pedestrian
([them0vieblog.com][2]).

- ---

### **Reception & Legacy**

* **The m0vie blog** criticized the sluggish
pacing and contrived plot, though acknowledged
Spiner’s strong dual performance ([them0vieblog.com][2]).

* **Den of Geek** praised the strong premise yet lamented
poor execution and narrative mishandling ([denofgeek.com][3]).

* **Tor.com (Keith DeCandido)** called it “horrendously bad,”
assigning 4/10, noting failures in script, body-doubling,
and character behavior ([en.wikipedia.org][1]).

* **Wil Wheaton** (via AOL TV) reflected fondness tempered
with criticism of lazy writing
and lack of surprise ([en.wikipedia.org][1]).

* **Michelle Erica Green** appreciated
Spiner’s work yet critiqued
the crew’s credulity and the narrative’s
unsatisfying conclusion ([en.wikipedia.org][1]).

- ---

### **Verdict**

“Datalore” serves as a mixed bag—a critical
turning point for Data’s development overshadowed
by narrative missteps. Spiner’s performance
and richer lore are strong assets, yet the episode
is weighed down by illogical plotting, contrived
pacing, and weak character responses. The Crystalline
Entity’s ominous presence hints at larger dangers,
but the story ultimately feels half-baked.

**Score: 3/10** – Worth a watch for Spiner's
dual performance and lore expansion, but flawed
structure and sloppy execution make it
a low-tier first-season episode.

- ---

Would you like an analysis of Lore’s return
in “Brothers” or insights into the Crystalline
Entity’s thematic role later on?

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Datalore?utm_source=chatgpt.com "Datalore" [2]: https://them0vieblog.com/2012/12/12/star-trek-the-next-generation-datalore-review/?utm_source=chatgpt.com "Star Trek: The Next Generation – Datalore (Review) | the m0vie blog"
[3]: https://www.denofgeek.com/tv/revisiting-star-trek-tng-datalore/?utm_source=chatgpt.com "Revisiting Star Trek TNG: Datalore | Den of Geek"
[4]: https://sagaofthejasonite.wordpress.com/star-trek-the-next-generation/season-one/review-of-episode-12-datalore/?utm_source=chatgpt.com "Review of Episode 12: Datalore | Saga of the Jasonite"


--
Member - Liberal International This is doctor@nk.ca Ici doctor@nk.ca
Yahweh, King & country!Never Satan President Republic!Beware AntiChrist rising! Look at Psalms 14 and 53 on Atheism ;
Australia -Save the Nation from Donald Trump - Vote out Albanese!

--- MBSE BBS v1.1.2 (Linux-x86_64)
* Origin: NetKnow News (3:633/280.2@fidonet)