Review Star Trek The Next AI/LLM reviews of Generation - Q Who?
Google Gemini
"Star Trek: The Next Generation - Q Who?" is a landmark episode,
not just for the series, but for the entire Star Trek franchise.
It delivers a terrifying and transformative encounter, forever
changing the landscape of the galaxy and introducing an iconic,
existential threat.
Plot Overview:
The episode begins with a seemingly innocuous
incident: Ensign Sonya Gomez has an embarrassing accident,
spilling hot chocolate on Captain Picard. This lighthearted
moment is quickly overshadowed by a growing sense of unease,
particularly from Guinan, who senses a profound disturbance.
The crew soon discovers Captain Picard missing, only to find
him on a shuttlecraft with the mischievous and omnipotent Q.
Q, expressing a desire to join the Enterprise crew, is firmly
denied by Picard. In response to this perceived
arrogance, Q, with a snap of his fingers, hurls
the Enterprise 7,000 light-years across the galaxy,
far beyond any known Federation space.
Marooned in this uncharted region, the Enterprise encounters
a planet that has been meticulously "scooped clean" of all life.
The true horror is revealed shortly after: they come face-to-face
with the Borg for the very first time. This encounter
is devastating; the Borg, with their relentless collective
consciousness and aggressive assimilation tactics, quickly
damage the Enterprise and kill eighteen crew members.
The crew is forced to confront a foe unlike any they have
ever faced – one that cannot be reasoned with, cannot be
defeated by conventional means, and whose only goal
is to add their biological and technological
distinctiveness to its own. Faced with overwhelming
odds and the imminent destruction of his ship, Picard,
in a moment of desperate humility, admits to Q that
they need his help. Q, having made his point about
humanity's unpreparedness for the dangers of the galaxy,
returns the Enterprise to its original location.
The episode concludes with Guinan's chilling
prophecy: Q has brought the Enterprise into
contact with the Borg far sooner than they
should have, and "they'll be coming."
Strengths:
Introduction of the Borg: This is the episode's
defining strength. The Borg are introduced as a
truly terrifying, unstoppable force, fundamentally
changing the nature of threats in Star Trek.
Their collective, their assimilation, and their
chilling catchphrases instantly cemented them
as iconic villains.
Q's Role: Q is at his absolute best here, acting
not just as a tormentor but as a cosmic provocateur,
forcing humanity to confront its limitations
and the vast, dangerous universe beyond its
comfortable borders. His interactions with Picard are brilliant.
High Stakes and Tension: The encounter with the Borg
is genuinely suspenseful and horrifying. The Enterprise
is outmatched and outgunned, creating a palpable sense
of dread and helplessness.
Picard's Humility: Picard's rare moment of admitting
defeat and asking for Q's help is a powerful character
beat, showcasing his growth as a leader willing to set
aside pride for the survival of his crew.
Guinan's Foresight: Guinan's mysterious knowledge
and her ominous warnings about the Borg add to the
episode's gravitas and foreshadow future conflicts.
Impact on the Franchise: This episode irrevocably
altered the course of Star Trek: The Next Generation
and the wider franchise, providing a long-running,
compelling antagonist.
Weaknesses:
Ensign Gomez Subplot (Minor): The initial subplot
with Ensign Gomez feels a bit out of place given
the monumental events that follow, though it serves
to establish a sense of normalcy before the chaos.
Dated Visuals (Minor): While the Borg ship design
is iconic, some of the visual effects for the Borg
drones and their attacks show their age, typical of early TNG.
Overall Impression:
"Q Who?" is a masterpiece of science fiction television
and a watershed moment for Star Trek: The Next Generation.
It is a terrifying, impactful, and utterly essential
episode that introduces the franchise's most iconic
and enduring villains, the Borg. With high stakes,
brilliant character work, and a profound shift in
the series' narrative scope, it stands as one
of the greatest and most influential episodes
in Star Trek history.
Rating: 9.8/10
ChatGPt
Alright — let’s break
down **“Star Trek: The Next Generation” — *Q Who*** using
the transcript from [chakoteya.net]
(
http://www.chakoteya.net/NextGen/142.htm).
- ---
**Episode:** *Q Who*
**Season:** 2, Episode 16
**Original Air Date:** May 8, 1989
- ---
## 📋 **Summary (from the transcript)**
Q returns — the trickster being who once
put humanity on trial in the pilot episode.
He proposes joining the Enterprise crew
to help them prepare for dangers they’re
not ready to face. Picard refuses, still
smarting from Q’s manipulations. To prove
his point, Q hurls the Enterprise 7,000 light
years into the unexplored Delta Quadrant,
where they encounter the Borg — a terrifying,
relentless collective of cybernetic beings
who consume technology
and life to expand themselves.
The Borg easily penetrate the Enterprise’s
defenses, carving out pieces of the ship
and kidnapping crew to analyse. Picard
realises they’re hopelessly outmatched.
Facing certain destruction, he admits
they need Q’s help after all. Q triumphantly
returns the ship home, gloating that he’s
done Picard a favour — showing him how
unprepared they truly are for what’s out there.
- ---
## ✅ **Strengths**
**➊ The Borg debut:** This is *the* episode
that introduces one of Trek’s most iconic,
chilling villains. They’re utterly alien,
efficient, and unstoppable — a perfect
sci-fi horror concept.
**➋ Q at his best:** John de Lancie
shines. He’s smug, dangerous,
and genuinely unsettling — not just
comic relief but a cosmic judge forcing
humanity to grow up.
**➌ Raises the stakes:** This episode
fundamentally changes TNG. The threat
of the Borg lingers all the way
to *Best of Both Worlds* and beyond.
The crew realises the galaxy is far
more dangerous than the Federation bubble.
** Picard’s humility:** This is one
of the best Picard moments in early
TNG — forced to beg Q for help
to save his crew. It humanises him
and shows true command: he sacrifices
his pride to protect his people.
**➎ Great production values:** The Borg
cube design, the eerie soundscape,
and the hive interior all look iconic,
especially for late-80s TV.
- ---
## ❌ **Weaknesses**
**➊ Pacing:** The first act is mostly
set-up and Q antics — some viewers feel
it takes too long to get to the Borg.
**➋ Guinan’s hints:** Guinan’s psychic
warnings about the Borg are intriguing
but vague. Her history with them
is barely touched on, which leaves
a lot unanswered.
**➌ Some “early Borg” oddities:** The Borg
here haven’t fully solidified into what
they’ll be later — they’re slightly more
insect-like scavengers than
the relentless assimilators of later canon.
- ---
## 🎭 **Standout moments**
* Q flicking the Enterprise across
the galaxy like it’s nothing.
* The Borg drone calmly scanning
and ignoring the crew — perfectly chilling.
* Picard’s bitter plea: *“If we’re to be
destroyed, let’s be destroyed together.”*
- ---
## 🗨️ **Best line**
**Q:** *“You’re not prepared for what awaits you.”*
This line foreshadows years of Trek
stories — it’s the moment the cozy Federation
realises space is *big and terrifying* again.
- ---
## ⭐ **Rating: 9/10**
**Verdict:** *Q Who* is one of TNG’s
pivotal early classics — suspenseful, impactful,
and essential viewing for any fan. It transforms
Q from mere nuisance to cosmic guide (or tormentor)
and introduces the Borg with maximum dread.
It also humbles the crew in a believable way,
setting the stage for some of the best arcs
in Trek history. A milestone episode that’s
just shy of perfect due to some rough edges
and minor pacing drag — but a clear standout.
--
Member - Liberal International This is
doctor@nk.ca Ici
doctor@nk.ca
Yahweh, King & country!Never Satan President Republic!Beware AntiChrist rising! Look at Psalms 14 and 53 on Atheism ;
All I want to hear from JEsus Christ is WEll done Good and Faithful servant
--- MBSE BBS v1.1.2 (Linux-x86_64)
* Origin: NetKnow News (3:633/280.2@fidonet)