• Re: PPB: July / Robert F. Skillings

    From W.Dockery@3:633/280.2 to All on Tue Dec 17 21:57:21 2024
    George J. Dance wrote:

    Will Dockery wrote:
    George J. Dance wrote:

    Will Dockery wrote:
    George J. Dance wrote:

    Today's poem on Penny's Poetry Blog:
    July, by Robert F. Skillings

    A very pleasant mo[n]th is this
    ÿÿÿÿ To be in a country town.
    The sunlight doth the foliage kiss
    [...]
    https://gdancesbetty.blogspot.com/2022/07/july-robert-f-skillings.html >>>>

    "Pleasant mouth"?

    A typo or a Edmund Spenser style spelling?

    Heh! I'd say it's a typo, though it is an interesting image, when
    combined with "kiss" in L3. So I've changed it to "month" on the blog,
    and changed it everywhere it's promoted on the web.

    Sadly, while it's probably a typo, it's on all the online copies I've
    seen -- I've looked at 3, and had to make decide which one to use (as
    they vary in whether or not they indent the lines). Yet all of them
    have "mouth". And I think I understand why. I must have read the poem
    6 times, and each time I read "month" -- and I expect that everyone
    else who put it on their site did the same.

    The other problem was that there's no authoritative source for the
    text online, just websites that appear to have simply c&p'd each
    other. I suspect that it's from one of the two anthologies Skillings's
    son says he had poems published in, but I haven't been able to find
    either. If it was typed in from a print book, that could explain the
    appearance of the "mouth."

    Thanks for bringing that to my attention here. There is a silver
    lining, when I or a reader catches an error like that: unlike the run
    of the mill poetry site, it gets corrected. So I'd say, provisionally,
    that unlike those other sites, PPB is a place to find a correct
    version of the poem.

    Again, it does seem to be a typo, and should be corrected, until further
    information surfaces.

    By luck, I was able to find the original publication. It's in this book,
    on this page (bottom left-hand corner).

    https://archive.org/details/localnationalpoe00herr/page/746/mode/2up

    It looks like a vanity press, and the type is small, but it can be blown
    up online, and it definitely says 'month'.

    That also led me to the source of the typo. It was made by the OCR
    scanner in the "Full Text" version of the poem, which just as definitely
    says 'mouth'.

    https://archive.org/stream/localnationalpoe00herr/localnationalpoe00herr_djvu.txt

    (You'll have to scroll down to the page. The easiest way is to Ctrl+F
    for "Skillings" - it takes just 2 clicks.)

    This was an interesting period in a.a.p.c. history.

    --- MBSE BBS v1.0.8.4 (Linux-x86_64)
    * Origin: novaBBS (3:633/280.2@fidonet)