I didn't see Blueshirt making a post about this episode, so I
have to make my own to comment, rather than reply to his.
Spoilers.
So, weird stuff, exciting stuff, weird exciting stuff.
Exciting weird stuff? What's going on?
Hello Anita! Nice to see you again. :)
Underverse? Like with the Necromongers in a Riddick movie?
Timelords infertile? How did that happen? What episode(s) do I
have to rewatch?
I think the new Rani fit the part better than Mrs Flood.
Was Poppy always Belinda's daughter, or did he just make that
real then?
Hello Madam Doctor! Nice to see you again. :)
Regeneration... I know that face... I know that face... Rose!
Oh, wow! Funny. :) Maybe her companion will be Doctor 14!
Where was Susan?
Mickmane wrote:
I didn't see Blueshirt making a post about this episode, so I
have to make my own to comment, rather than reply to his.
It's there... somewhere. Although it was more a rant about RTD's
writing than a proper review. It served the same purpose though.
Spoilers.
So, weird stuff, exciting stuff, weird exciting stuff.
Exciting weird stuff? What's going on?
I doubt anyone knew what was going on... just when I thought I
had a grasp of it, off it went in another direction.
Hello Anita! Nice to see you again. :)
Please hold the door open for me. Thanks.
Underverse? Like with the Necromongers in a Riddick movie?
I got "Stranger Things" vibes from it.
Timelords infertile? How did that happen? What episode(s) do I
have to rewatch?
This one! RTD just made it up.
I think the new Rani fit the part better than Mrs Flood.
She fitted into Omega's mouth better anyway... he didn't fancy
the old woman version, too chewy... he wanted tender meat.
Was Poppy always Belinda's daughter, or did he just make that
real then?
Who knows? Oh hang on, I know someone who might...
russelltdavies@badwolfproductions.com
Ask him.
Hello Madam Doctor! Nice to see you again. :)
And the nay-sayers back in 2023 thought RTD would retcon her!
He didn't just double-down, he tripled down on it!
Jodie's Doctor was completely unnecessary to the story though.
She was just another season finale gimmick. (Another egg in the
pudding.)
Regeneration... I know that face... I know that face... Rose!
Oh, wow! Funny. :) Maybe her companion will be Doctor 14!
If I was a betting man I would put twenty quid on David Tennant
being involved in the next series of Doctor Who (whenever that
is) in some form or another.
Where was Susan?
Who? If Time Lords can't have children they can't have
grand-children! So she can't exist, can she? ;-)
The correct answer though is... she was lost in the void
behind the monitor in the TARDIS.
On 02.06.25, Blueshirt <blueshirt@indigo.news> wrote:
Mickmane wrote:
I didn't see Blueshirt making a post about this episode, so
I have to make my own to comment, rather than reply to his.
It's there... somewhere. Although it was more a rant about
RTD's writing than a proper review. It served the same
purpose though.
I think I've seen that, but it doesn't have the subject line
about this episode.
[Snip]
Timelords infertile? How did that happen? What episode(s)
do I have to rewatch?
This one! RTD just made it up.
Oh. And what did they use as excuse event to cause it?
Hello Madam Doctor! Nice to see you again. :)
And the nay-sayers back in 2023 thought RTD would retcon her!
He didn't just double-down, he tripled down on it!
I don't understand what they don't like about her. She was a
great Doctor (with terrible scripts).
At least she got enough genius Doctor rambling and
fixing/building things. Doctor 15 didn't really, on top of
mostly incoherent scripts.
Jodie's Doctor was completely unnecessary to the story
though. She was just another season finale gimmick.
(Another egg in the pudding.)
[shrug] That doesn't bother me at all in this case.
Regeneration... I know that face... I know that face...
Rose! Oh, wow! Funny. :) Maybe her companion will be
Doctor 14!
If I was a betting man I would put twenty quid on David
Tennant being involved in the next series of Doctor Who
(whenever that is) in some form or another.
I'm not in the habit of betting either. I just keep up hope!
:) He's out there, somewhere!
Where was Susan?
Who? If Time Lords can't have children they can't have
grand-children! So she can't exist, can she? ;-)
I thought they said that infertility thing was caused by
something relatively recently/to do with the destruction of
the Time Lords.
Thing is, they got destroyed and then came back later so
often, I don't remember what the last such event was.
The correct answer though is... she was lost in the void
behind the monitor in the TARDIS.
I didn't notice that she was on a monitor, I thought she was
in the Doctor's mind. (At least when he was out in space,
frozen.)
Btw, did anyone mention gravity/mavity after the reality fix?
Maybe it went back to normal too?
Whatever you do, don't mention Looms!!!
Mickmane maintained:
On 02.06.25, Blueshirt <blueshirt@indigo.news> wrote:
Mickmane wrote:
I don't understand what they don't like about her. She was a
great Doctor (with terrible scripts).
She didn?t have a penis. That?s enough for some people.
(Apparently straight, white, cisgender males can only ever watch
programmes about straight, white, cisgender males or else
they?ll instantly turn woke which is a fate worse than death. Or
something.)
Jodie's Doctor was completely unnecessary to the story though.
She was just another season finale gimmick. (Another egg in the
pudding.)
[shrug] That doesn't bother me at all in this case.
She wasn?t completely unnecessary. The Doctor needed someone
there so that he could explain that he was going to use his
regeneration energy to fix the universe. But not a companion who
would just ask sensible questions about how and why he
can fix it like that and why has he never done anything like
this before, etc.
OTOH the downside of bringing in another Doctor is that they
could each contribute a half-dose of regeneration energy so
NcutiDoc wouldn?t burn out and need to regenerate after all.
(Worse, they even reminded us that DavidDoc is still around. He
could add his energy to the mix too. The more the better.)
Where was Susan?
Who? If Time Lords can't have children they can't have
grand-children! So she can't exist, can she? ;-)
I thought they said that infertility thing was caused by something
relatively recently/to do with the destruction of the Time Lords.
That was my impression too, especially since the Rani used
very similar expressions to describe them both.
But we seem to be the only ones who interpret it that way.
Thing is, they got destroyed and then came back later so often, I
don't remember what the last such event was.
The ?O? Master did it between Whittaker?s first two seasons.
Btw, did anyone mention gravity/mavity after the reality fix? Maybe
it went back to normal too?
Unfortunately not. It?s still there as yet another unresolved plot
strand, alongside Susan, the Boss, the Toymaker?s tooth, etc.
On 2/06/2025 7:07 pm, Mickmane wrote:
On 02.06.25, Blueshirt <blueshirt@indigo.news> wrote:
<Snip>
Who? If Time Lords can't have children they can't have
grand-children! So she can't exist, can she? ;-)
I thought they said that infertility thing was caused by something
relatively recently/to do with the destruction of the Time Lords.
Could this have been a side effect of Gualifray being placed in a mini-Universe thingee following the Time War .... which was only
about 25 Gualifrean (Timey Whimey) years ago??
As far as I remember (badly), the infertility was explained in
?Lungbarrow?. Not an episode, but an actual book, released in 1997.
Jens K. Loewe wrote:
As far as I remember (badly), the infertility was explained in
?Lungbarrow?. Not an episode, but an actual book, released in
1997.
Whatever you do, don't mention Looms!!!
Blueshirt <blueshirt@indigo.news> wrote:
Whatever you do, don't mention Looms!!!
I would never!
In article <xn0p6kcui2l88bc001@post.eweka.nl>,
Blueshirt <blueshirt@indigo.news> wrote:
Mickmane wrote:
Where was Susan?
Who? If Time Lords can't have children they can't have
grand-children! So she can't exist, can she? ;-)
The correct answer though is... she was lost in the void
behind the monitor in the TARDIS.
Yet another contradiction.
On 03.06.25, Jens K. Loewe <jens.k.loewe@googlemail.com>
wrote:
As far as I remember (badly), the infertility was explained
in ?Lungbarrow?. Not an episode, but an actual book,
released in 1997.
Never heard of that.
On 03.06.25, Blueshirt <blueshirt@indigo.news> wrote:
Jens K. Loewe wrote:
As far as I remember (badly), the infertility was explained
in "Lungbarrow". Not an episode, but an actual book,
released in 1997.
Whatever you do, don't mention Looms!!!
Why?
THey should have picked up from McCoy and Aldred from 1989.
In article <101mgb6$3u7b5$1@dont-email.me>,
solar penguin <solar.penguin@gmail.com> wrote:
The infertility was tied to a specific origin for the
Time Lords and the Doctor that’s now been junked for the
Timeless Child instead.
Put simply, millennia ago a witch cursed Gallifrey (yes,
really!) turning it infertile. All new Time Lords were
clones grown in genetic Looms (including the Doctor, who’s
the clone of an ancient Time Lord scientist called the
Other.)
I’m simplifying a little bit, but you get the idea.
And that contradicts the timeless Child.
Mickmane <ATH@kruemel.org> wrote:
On 03.06.25, Jens K. Loewe <jens.k.loewe@googlemail.com>
wrote:
As far as I remember (badly), the infertility was explained
in "Lungbarrow". Not an episode, but an actual book,
released in 1997.
Never heard of that.
That’s OK. The infertility was tied to a specific origin for
the Time Lords and the Doctor that’s now been junked for the
Timeless Child instead.
Put simply, millennia ago a witch cursed Gallifrey (yes,
really!) turning it infertile. All new Time Lords were clones
grown in genetic Looms (including the Doctor, who’s the clone
of an ancient Time Lord scientist called the Other.)
I’m simplifying a little bit, but you get the idea.
The Meep and Anita both mentioned having a boss. (No reason
for thinking they’re the same boss, but fans are speculating
that another word for Boss is Master.)
Mickmane mentioned:
On 03.06.25, solar penguin <solar.penguin@gmail.com> wrote:
Mickmane maintained:
Btw, did anyone mention gravity/mavity after the reality fix?
Maybe it went back to normal too?
Unfortunately not. It?s still there as yet another unresolved plot
strand, alongside Susan, the Boss, the Toymaker?s tooth, etc.
The Boss?
The Meep and Anita both mentioned having a boss. (No reason
for thinking they?re the same boss, but fans are speculating that
another word for Boss is Master.)
On 3/06/2025 6:18 pm, Mickmane wrote:
On 03.06.25, Daniel70 <daniel47@eternal-september.org> wrote:
On 2/06/2025 7:07 pm, Mickmane wrote:
Yes, I think so.I thought they said that infertility thing was caused by something
relatively recently/to do with the destruction of the Time Lords.
Could this have been a side effect of Gualifray being placed in a
mini-Universe thingee following the Time War .... which was only
about 25 Gualifrean (Timey Whimey) years ago??
Was that the last time they were destroyed, in the series?
Mickmane <ATH@kruemel.org> wrote:
On 03.06.25, Jens K. Loewe <jens.k.loewe@googlemail.com> wrote:
As far as I remember (badly), the infertility was explained in
?Lungbarrow?. Not an episode, but an actual book, released in 1997.
Never heard of that.
That?s OK. The infertility was tied to a specific origin for the
Time Lords and the Doctor that?s now been junked for the
Timeless Child instead.
Put simply, millennia ago a witch cursed Gallifrey (yes, really!)
turning it infertile. All new Time Lords were clones grown in
genetic Looms (including the Doctor, who?s the clone of an
ancient Time Lord scientist called the Other.)
I?m simplifying a little bit, but you get the idea.
Mickmane wrote:
On 03.06.25, Blueshirt <blueshirt@indigo.news> wrote:
Jens K. Loewe wrote:
As far as I remember (badly), the infertility was explained
in "Lungbarrow". Not an episode, but an actual book,
released in 1997.
Whatever you do, don't mention Looms!!!
Why?
Here's a link to a review of the book... it's easier than
explaining it! Some people love "Lungbarrow", I wouldn't be too
fussed over it. It was a good read, Marc Platt is an excellent
Doctor Who author, I'm just not the type to get worked up over
Gallifrey and Time Lord lore.
https://doctorwhoreviews.co.uk/NA60.htm
Blueshirt <blueshirt@indigo.news> wrote:
solar penguin wrote:
The Meep and Anita both mentioned having a boss. (No reason
for thinking they’re the same boss, but fans are speculating
that another word for Boss is Master.)
Well, RTD has already brought back The 10th Doctor, Donna,
The Toymaker, Sutekh, The Rani, Omega, Susan, The 13th
Doctor and Rose Tyler... of course the Master is going to be
next on his list. <rolls eyes>
Or he could actually be bringing back BOSS from The Green
Death. (Except now BOSS is the god of computers and looks
like a CGI giant lizard.)
In article <xn0p6m9mq7jhob5006@post.eweka.nl>,
Blueshirt <blueshirt@indigo.news> wrote:
solar penguin wrote:
The Meep and Anita both mentioned having a boss. (No reason
for thinking they’re the same boss, but fans are speculating
that another word for Boss is Master.)
Well, RTD has already brought back The 10th Doctor, Donna,
The Toymaker, Sutekh, The Rani, Omega, Susan, The 13th
Doctor and Rose Tyler... of course the Master is going to be
next on his list. <rolls eyes>
NO.
On 04.06.25, Blueshirt <blueshirt@indigo.news> wrote:
Here's a link to a review of the book... it's easier than
explaining it! Some people love "Lungbarrow", I wouldn't be
too fussed over it though. It was a good read, and Marc
Platt is an excellent Doctor Who author, I'm just not the
type to get worked up over Gallifrey and Time Lord lore.
https://doctorwhoreviews.co.uk/NA60.htm
Sounds like weirdo fanfic. I don't think anything that's not
on screen is valid. (And even there not everything is accepted
when it doesn't make sense.)
On 04.06.25, solar penguin <solar.penguin@gmail.com> wrote:
Mickmane mentioned:
The Boss?
The Meep and Anita both mentioned having a boss. (No reason
for thinking they?re the same boss, but fans are speculating
that another word for Boss is Master.)
I remember Anita saying something about a boss. Went back
skipping through the episode to find it. The boss is actually
a 'they'. Hm.
On 4/06/2025 5:34 am, Blueshirt wrote:
solar penguin wrote:
The Meep and Anita both mentioned having a boss. (No reason
for thinking they’re the same boss, but fans are
speculating that another word for Boss is Master.)
Well, RTD has already brought back The 10th Doctor, Donna,
The Toymaker, Sutekh, The Rani, Omega, Susan, The 13th
Doctor and Rose Tyler... of course the Master is going to be
next on his list. <rolls eyes>
Aren't The (Human) 13th Doctor and Rose off on a Beach
somewhere??
Mickmane wrote:
On 04.06.25, solar penguin <solar.penguin@gmail.com> wrote:
Mickmane mentioned:
The Boss?
The Meep and Anita both mentioned having a boss. (No reason
for thinking they?re the same boss, but fans are speculating
that another word for Boss is Master.)
I remember Anita saying something about a boss. Went back
skipping through the episode to find it. The boss is actually
a 'they'. Hm.
If it's not two Master's... Daleks!!!
If it's one boss, and not the Master... deffo Davros then.
:-)
On 05.06.25, Blueshirt <blueshirt@indigo.news> wrote:
Mickmane wrote:
I remember Anita saying something about a boss. Went
back skipping through the episode to find it. The boss
is actually a 'they'. Hm.
If it's not two Master's... Daleks!!!
If it's one boss, and not the Master... deffo Davros then.
You missed Cybermen.
But who of these would tell Anita to "say Hello" to the
Doctor? Sounds like the Master.
Mickmane wrote:
On 05.06.25, Blueshirt <blueshirt@indigo.news> wrote:
If it's not two Master's... Daleks!!!
If it's one boss, and not the Master... deffo Davros then.
You missed Cybermen.
Why would I mention them? Stupid tin men.
But who of these would tell Anita to "say Hello" to the
Doctor? Sounds like the Master.
Yeah. My money would be on the Master...
As I said yesterday, if the planned 'big bad' for S3/16 was
the Master it wouldn't have surprised me. In fact, the Master
not turning up in S3/S16 would actually be a bigger surprise.
On 06.06.25, Blueshirt <blueshirt@indigo.news> wrote:
Yeah. My money would be on the Master...
As I said yesterday, if the planned 'big bad' for S3/16 was
the Master it wouldn't have surprised me. In fact, the Master
not turning up in S3/S16 would actually be a bigger surprise.
Maybe "Rose" is the Master, stealing the regeneration. (The
thought just hit me, I just got up, not awake yet. :) )
Mickmane wrote:
On 06.06.25, Blueshirt <blueshirt@indigo.news> wrote:
Yeah. My money would be on the Master...
As I said yesterday, if the planned 'big bad' for S3/16 was
the Master it wouldn't have surprised me. In fact, the Master
not turning up in S3/S16 would actually be a bigger surprise.
Maybe "Rose" is the Master, stealing the regeneration. (The
thought just hit me, I just got up, not awake yet. :) )
PLEASE... Don't be giving RTD ideas!!!
On 07.06.25, Blueshirt <blueshirt@indigo.news> wrote:
Mickmane wrote:
On 06.06.25, Blueshirt <blueshirt@indigo.news> wrote:
Yeah. My money would be on the Master...
As I said yesterday, if the planned 'big bad' for S3/16 was
the Master it wouldn't have surprised me. In fact, the Master
not turning up in S3/S16 would actually be a bigger surprise.
Maybe "Rose" is the Master, stealing the regeneration. (The
thought just hit me, I just got up, not awake yet. :) )
PLEASE... Don't be giving RTD ideas!!!
Would that be so much worse than what he's been doing on his own lately?
:)
On 6/7/2025 03:42, Mickmane wrote:
On 07.06.25, Blueshirt <blueshirt@indigo.news> wrote:
Mickmane wrote:
Maybe "Rose" is the Master, stealing the regeneration.
(The thought just hit me, I just got up, not awake yet.)
PLEASE... Don't be giving RTD ideas!!!
Would that be so much worse than what he's been doing on his
own lately? :)
It depends...will Omega be summoned again, and continue eating
Time Lords? :)
On 6/7/2025 03:42, Mickmane wrote:
On 07.06.25, Blueshirt <blueshirt@indigo.news> wrote:
Mickmane wrote:
Maybe "Rose" is the Master, stealing the regeneration. (The
thought just hit me, I just got up, not awake yet. :) )
PLEASE... Don't be giving RTD ideas!!!
Would that be so much worse than what he's been doing on his own
lately? :)
It depends...will Omega be summoned again, and continue eating Time
Lords? :)
Sysop: | Tetrazocine |
---|---|
Location: | Melbourne, VIC, Australia |
Users: | 8 |
Nodes: | 8 (0 / 8) |
Uptime: | 89:26:55 |
Calls: | 161 |
Files: | 21,502 |
Messages: | 78,348 |