1. Forum
  2. Fidonet
  3. ALT.TV.STAR-TREK.TOS

  • In Star Trek VI, the Enterprise meets up with the Klingon battle cruise

    From MummyChunk@3:633/280.2 to All on Tue Oct 22 05:30:21 2024
    Subject: In Star Trek VI, the Enterprise meets up with the Klingon battle cruiser. As the cruiser appears on the viewscreen, Kirk (in the still shown here) looks with some awe and says, "I've never been this close".

    In Star Trek VI, the Enterprise meets up with the Klingon battle
    cruiser. As the cruiser appears on the viewscreen, Kirk (in the still
    shown here) looks with some awe and says, "I've never been this
    close".

    Anyone understand this line? He had done hand-to-hand combat with
    Klingons. He actually boarded and took over a Klingon vessel in Star
    Trek III, then commanded the Klingon vessel all the way through Star
    Trek IV, then boarded another Klingon vessel in Star Trek V.

    Why, then, in Star Trek VI, does he act as if he has never been this
    close to a Klingon vessel before, or to a Klingon before?

    Perhaps based on his line to Spock earlier in the film, when he says
    "Let them die"... in this moment the anger in him has been
    stewing since they launched, and seeing that ship up close, knowing
    who was on board...

    Maybe in that moment he was very much aware that given the state of
    the Empire, he could order that ship destroyed and it would be the
    closest the Federation would come to fully defeating the Klingon
    Empire.

    The line could be a commentary on the infectious nature of hate. Maybe
    he really didn’t mean and it only showed where his mind was soon
    before those torpedoes actually hit.

    That action… seeing it truly woke and shocked his moral center.
    Perhaps it made him feel tremendous guilt, even in the uncertainty of
    whether or not it was Enterprise that fired, in that it was what he
    WANTED to do... and it sort of breaks him, and ultimately changes him.
    It's part of the most human journey they could have given Kirk.

    Kirk was such a flawed character, clever, but ultimately that he could experience these things and come out of it inspiring change that would
    change the Federation for the better, and truly show the best of what
    Star Trek has to offer.

    View the attachments for this post at: http://www.jlaforums.com/viewtopic.php?p=676632228#676632228


    --- MBSE BBS v1.0.8.4 (Linux-x86_64)
    * Origin: ---:- FTN<->UseNet Gate -:--- (3:633/280.2@fidonet)