that but also says I have no new messages every time. So I can no longer download packets at all.

You can set your download message date for your QWK it should be on the menu, unless 20 beers removed it for some reason.

Quick question: Are you downloading by FTP or from the BBS? I forgot to ask that. The FTP engine is "new" from 2010 or so, and the BBS one is from 1997 ( different code unfortunately).

I did release an unconfirmed fix, but its going to take time for Paulie to upgrade. The newer version has some changes to data files and he is doing some
offline testing first.

You are more than welcome to download Mystic and try to reproduce the problem if you'd like to help resolve it. The latest "cutting edge" release is: www.mysticbbs.com/downloads/prealpha/paulie

.... Documentation: The worst part of programming.


--- MBSE BBS v1.0.8 (Linux-x86_64)
* Origin: Agency HUB, Dunedin - New Zealand (1:129/215@fidonet)

g00r00 wrote to Rick Sanchez <=-

that but also says I have no new messages every time. So I can no longer download packets at all.

You can set your download message date for your QWK it should be on the menu, unless 20 beers removed it for some reason.

Quick question: Are you downloading by FTP or from the BBS? I forgot
to ask that. The FTP engine is "new" from 2010 or so, and the BBS one
is from 1997 ( different code unfortunately).

I am downloading via the BBS, not with FTP. 20 For doesn't have a date set
in the QWK menu. I am trying to leave it 'broken' so paulie can see what is doing the next time I can catch him when we are both on the BBS.
iNoNaMouSe
14.4kps From Your Local Victoria's Secret
.... A man's incomplete until married; then he's finished!
=== MultiMail/Win v0.52

--- MBSE BBS v1.0.8 (Linux-x86_64)
* Origin: Agency HUB, Dunedin - New Zealand (4593:770/1@fidonet)

I am downloading via the BBS, not with FTP. 20 For doesn't have a date set in the QWK menu. I am trying to leave it 'broken' so paulie can see what is doing the next time I can catch him when we are both on the BBS.

Gotcha. There should be a set message date on the message menu and it works for both QWK and your own BBS last read pointers.

Here is my theory:

When you download a QWK packet, Mystic starts at your last read message + 1. When the last read was updated, it was setting it as last read + 1. When Mystic's message base packer was packing everything, it found that the last read message was an invalid message number and was resetting it to 0.

I do think its fixed in the "Paulie" build but we'll see. I didn't start with a reproducable issue on my end so I can't be certain.

I've also switched to using a mixture of MultiMail QWK and online Mystic to see
if I can catch the "fixed" version doing the same stuff. I'll be packing the message bases daily as well.

We'll get it sorted out and a new stable release out once its done and Paulie confirms any issues he has regarding file bases is okay!

.... Kilometers are shorter than miles. Save gas, take your trip in kilometers


--- MBSE BBS v1.0.8 (Linux-x86_64)
* Origin: Agency HUB, Dunedin - New Zealand (1:129/215@fidonet)

Paulie runs maintenance very night at midnight, and that doesn't seem to mess up these last read pointers. However, my best guess at the moment
is it seems almost weekly. I am not sure if there is some maintenance

I am wondering if he does a weekly message base pack, which is along the lines of what I recommend at least. I don't recommend people run it nightly because what it does is completely recreates the message bases from scratch based on the existing data. "Pack" isn't really a good word for it but its intensive.

Lets hope its a weekly thing for him and we'll see it fixed in the new one!

.... Do vegetarians eat animal crackers?


--- MBSE BBS v1.0.8 (Linux-x86_64)
* Origin: Agency HUB, Dunedin - New Zealand (1:129/215@fidonet)

g00r00 wrote to Rick Sanchez <=-

Soo... I am not sure which BBS package I will end up going with now. :(

You've reported a bug about 3 days ago, and one which no one has
reported ever in 20+ years. If your reaction is to throw in the towel
in a couple days after you find a bug, you're probably best not using
any BBS lol

I am not throwing in the towel, hence why I keep trying to help figure out
what is causing this issue to happen. I prefer Mystic over any other BBS software, but I also prefer to read and respond to all my FTN mail via 'offline' methods. So hoping to make both work.

Paulie runs maintenance very night at midnight, and that doesn't seem to
mess up these last read pointers. However, my best guess at the moment
is it seems almost weekly. I am not sure if there is some maintenance
that only happens on a more weekly type of basis that may be messing
up last read somehow.
iNoNaMouSe
14.4kps From Your Local Victoria's Secret
.... I'm Buy-sexual, I have to pay for it.
=== MultiMail/Win v0.52

--- MBSE BBS v1.0.8 (Linux-x86_64)
* Origin: Agency HUB, Dunedin - New Zealand (4594:770/1@fidonet)

On Tuesday, January 31, 2023 at 11:20:19 AM UTC-6, Rick Sanchez wrote:

This was Mystic on Linux at the time. I haven't run it on MacOS yet. But=

=20

I think I should be able to make most of everything I had working on Mac=

=20

as well. I guess maybe I shall find out. However, I may have to look a=20 different direction if I cannot help figure out what causes Mystic's=20
QWK mail handling to be so poor. Three Mystic BBS's I've tried to rely=20 solely on QWK packets for all message handling have failed. After about=

=20

a week or so on each, Mystic loses my last read pointers and I then have=

=20

thousands of new messsages again. This time, on 20 For Beers, it did that=

=20

but also says I have no new messages every time. So I can no longer=20 download packets at all.=20
=20
Soo... I am not sure which BBS package I will end up going with now. :(

Any thoughts of using Hermes II? I know it's old but I've got the unreleas=
ed 3.5.11 version up and running via TCP and it seems to be pretty stable i=
n OS9. Same issue with the door games though - I can only get two to work = (Leech and Blackjack Pro). Not sure, but maybe there would be a way to con= nect to the game servers using a Python external or if you're handy with TH= INK Pascal...

-BK

--- MBSE BBS v1.0.8 (Linux-x86_64)
* Origin: ---:- FTN<->UseNet Gate -:--- (3:633/280.2@fidonet)

g00r00 wrote to Rick Sanchez <=-

Gotcha. There should be a set message date on the message menu and it works for both QWK and your own BBS last read pointers.

Here is my theory:

When you download a QWK packet, Mystic starts at your last read message
+ 1. When the last read was updated, it was setting it as last read +
1. When Mystic's message base packer was packing everything, it found that the last read message was an invalid message number and was
resetting it to 0.

I do think its fixed in the "Paulie" build but we'll see. I didn't
start with a reproducable issue on my end so I can't be certain.

I've also switched to using a mixture of MultiMail QWK and online
Mystic to see if I can catch the "fixed" version doing the same stuff. I'll be packing the message bases daily as well.

We'll get it sorted out and a new stable release out once its done and Paulie confirms any issues he has regarding file bases is okay!

Your description of what you think is happening, does sound very plausible
and was what I was already suspecting was going on. I shall see what happens over this next week or two on 20forbeers and see if it doesn't happen again
in about the same amount of time.
iNoNaMouSe
14.4kps From Your Local Victoria's Secret
.... Politicians cut red tape....LENGTHWISE
=== MultiMail/Win v0.52

--- MBSE BBS v1.0.8 (Linux-x86_64)
* Origin: Agency HUB, Dunedin - New Zealand (4598:770/1@fidonet)

On 31 Jan 23 14:08:32, G00R00 said the following to Rick Sanchez:

Lets hope its a weekly thing for him and we'll see it fixed in the new one!

And the stereophonic Cowbell notification feature, where is that?

Nick


--- MBSE BBS v1.0.8 (Linux-x86_64)
* Origin: Agency HUB, Dunedin - New Zealand (1:229/426@fidonet)

Lets hope its a weekly thing for him and we'll see it fixed in the new

And the stereophonic Cowbell notification feature, where is that?

The Dolby Atmos SysOp cowbell is scheduled to be included in version 42.
..

.... Anything is possible if you don't know what you're talking about


--- MBSE BBS v1.0.8 (Linux-x86_64)
* Origin: Agency HUB, Dunedin - New Zealand (1:129/215@fidonet)

plausible and was what I was already suspecting was going on. I shall see what happens over this next week or two on 20forbeers and see if it doesn't happen again in about the same amount of time.

I don't know what his upgrade timeline is so it may happen again because he hasn't upgraded yet. I know he wanted to experiment with that build before upgrading because it has some data file changes.

.... Everyone is entitled to my opinion!


--- MBSE BBS v1.0.8 (Linux-x86_64)
* Origin: Agency HUB, Dunedin - New Zealand (1:129/215@fidonet)

Byte Knight (Captain's Quarters II wrote to iNoNaMouSe <=-

Any thoughts of using Hermes II? I know it's old but I've got the unreleased 3.5.11 version up and running via TCP and it seems to be pretty stable in OS9. Same issue with the door games though - I can
only get two to work (Leech and Blackjack Pro). Not sure, but maybe
there would be a way to connect to the game servers using a Python external or if you're handy with THINK Pascal...

I would most likely prefer something still in active development if possible.


iNoNaMouSe
14.4kps From Your Local Victoria's Secret
.... We're testing as QWK as we can
___ MultiMail/Win v0.52


--- MBSE BBS v1.0.8 (Linux-x86_64)
* Origin: Agency HUB, Dunedin - New Zealand (1:105/420@fidonet)

And the stereophonic Cowbell notification feature, where is that?

We don't need more cowbell, BUT, when necessary, it simply must be sterophonic. There is a time and a place. :-)


..

Mick Manning
Bad Poetry Blues (badpoet.synchro.net:2300) gopher://centralontarioremote.com:70

--- MBSE BBS v1.0.8 (Linux-x86_64)
* Origin: Agency HUB, Dunedin - New Zealand (240:770/1@fidonet)

I don't know what his upgrade timeline is so it may happen again because he hasn't upgraded yet. I know he wanted to experiment with that build before upgrading because it has some data file changes.

I am not sure if he implemented the new build or not yet. It did happen again after this Sunday night. So it is happening on whatever BBS maintenance he is running weekly. Maybe he will chime in to this message when he sees it and confirm what build he is using and what maintenance he is running weekly.


iNoNaMouSe
Hacking at 14.4kbps from your local Victoria's Secret...

.... Yo mama's got a wooden leg with a kickstand on it


--- MBSE BBS v1.0.8 (Linux-x86_64)
* Origin: Agency HUB, Dunedin - New Zealand (1:105/420@fidonet)

I am not sure if he implemented the new build or not yet. It did happen again after this Sunday night. So it is happening on whatever BBS maintenance he is running weekly. Maybe he will chime in to this

It doesn't seem like he has implemented the fixed build yet, unfortunately. I have been testing here off and on and there hasn't been any issue yet for me, so I am hoping the new one fixes is.

.... A Meteor is an example of a rock star.


--- MBSE BBS v1.0.8 (Linux-x86_64)
* Origin: Agency HUB, Dunedin - New Zealand (1:129/215@fidonet)